Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Tile vs Laminate Wood

who's talking here?

Keystone 2
whatchamacallit 8
june 2
la guerita 2
Fallon 2
mamadog53 1
needrnr 2
luv2shop 1
rose8304 3
NoNameNoLastName 1
ladybeachbum 2
addipie 1
2girlygirls 2
Tessa 1
ghostpost 2
fishlady 1
Atasca Mom 3
4boys 1
picasso1 1
Lillabeth 2
justcat 1
Nightstorm 1
Paige Paige 2
Danabug 3
SueRDH 1
Ogre1 1
bigla 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Tile vs Laminate Wood

We are thinking of redoing our entire downstairs in the future. I was leaning towards laminate wood, but my dh wants ceramic tile. I just cannot picture a tile that I would want on my ENTIRE downstairs! Do you have one? Which is better? If you have tile floors for a whole floor or huge room and would like to share pictures, I would really love to see them!

Ceramic Tile Vote
 
 72.2% (26)
Laminate Wood Vote
 
 27.8% (10)
rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

We are thinking of redoing our entire downstairs in the future. I was leaning towards laminate wood, but my dh wants ceramic tile. I just cannot picture a tile that I would want on my ENTIRE downstairs! Do you have one? Which is better? If you have tile floors for a whole floor or huge room and would like to share pictures, I would really love to see them!  

Nightstorm --- 17 years ago -

Neither. Laminate looks fake and ceramic is cold-looking. I'd rather have real wood or carpet. 

Paige Paige --- 17 years ago -

If you can't do real wood, I would go for the tile. jmo... 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

I think we've decided against real wood for sure. 

la guerita --- 17 years ago -

maybe you can break it up some. we have wood in the living area, tile in the kitchen and dining, and carpet in the bedrooms. i agree tile can be cold looking in some areas, depending on the tile. 

Paige Paige --- 17 years ago -

I have seen many $$$houses with tile that look fantastic. I will search HAR and post a few pics for you. I like the slate look, or travertine, or even stamped concrete. You can really use some rich looking tiles. And if you can, use the large ones placed at an angle. 

Atasca Mom --- 17 years ago -

maybe you can break it up some. we have wood in the living area, tile in the kitchen and dining, and carpet in the bedrooms That's what I have... I will post a link to the thread from my remod. 

Atasca Mom --- 17 years ago -

link title 

june --- 17 years ago -

We did tile in our den and love it. We have wood in the dining room, bedroom etc. but opted for tile in the den for ease of maintence. We installed a warm color so it doesn't seem cold. I think a light color might not be a good choice for that reason. I have decided I want to add an area rug under the coffee table area just to soften the look a bit, but we get lots of compliments on the tile as it is. I LOVE the maintence --or low maintence of the tile. 

Tessa --- 17 years ago -

we have tile and laminate wood in our downstairs. Tile in the kitchen, entryway, and bathroom. Wood in the two front rooms and the living room. Recently had a plumbing issue and it ruined the floor in the living room. Of course, the tile is fine... The ruined wood floor is coming up...more tile going in. You can't go wrong with tile IMO. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Neither. Real wood floor is the way to go. It looks great. Tile in places like the kitchen and the baths. Other than that, wood. I hope to do that someday, right now I have ugly beige carpet. The other option, stained concrete. but it's pricey. 

la guerita --- 17 years ago -

Atasca Mom our floors are the same colors too lol 

Atasca Mom --- 17 years ago -

I have a roomba and it takes care of the wood and tile. I am VERY pleased with my choices. I sought advice from KU too :) 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Don't use laminate. I have what is SUPPOSED to be a quality laminate (Pergo) in my my family room, dining room, kitchen and hallways. Every time there is any moisture on the floor, it buckles. I am not kidding, drop an icecube and not pick it up before it melts and you have a spot where the "boards" raise up on the edges. I am going to put tile in the whole house. There are some fantastic tiles available and you can always add large rugs to areas where you want a little more warmth in the room. If they get dirty and can't be cleaned to your satisfaction, you can kick them to the curb. Rugs, unlike carpet can't really be cleaned. With carpet, no matter how diligent you are about vacuuming or cleaning there is always "yuck" underneath when you pull it up to replace it. Tile w/area rugs. The cleanest, most durable, easiest to clean flooring option. 

Keystone --- 17 years ago -

Don't use laminate. I have what is SUPPOSED to be a quality laminate (Pergo) in my my family room, dining room, kitchen and hallways. Every time there is any moisture on the floor, it buckles. I am not kidding, drop an icecube and not pick it up before it melts and you have a spot where the "boards" raise up on the edges. Some others of you don't like laminate as well. Are there other reasons? We, too, are trying to make the decision tile vs. wood (laminate). It would also be nice to hear what people DO like about laminate, if anything. 

4boys --- 17 years ago -

We have laminate and tile downstairs in our house. I like the laminate better but it does have it's down sides. It scratches --tiny scratches when you don't vacuum it often enough -- and we vacuum at least every other day. We don't have problems with moisture or buckling. And I like the way laminate looks better than tile, personally. 

2girlygirls --- 17 years ago -

I hate the streaks that are left when you clean laminate, the plastic sound it makes when you walk on it with shoes and the issues with water and buckling. I'd go with a nice, warm-colored tile over laminate. There are other products out there that look similar to wood. Look at Karndean.com. They have a product that looks like wood and is even textured like wood that is made of out pvc. The tile store on 1960 (Flooring America) sells it and has it on display there. It looks much more realistic that laminate. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

We are going to go with slate downstairs. A lot of homes are using slate. And it looks great. Do not use carpet. Got to be the worse thing you can do, for allergies, and it impossible to ever keep it clean. I have a huge inside dog, so that is the main reason I did not choose wood for downstairs. He would mess any of it up. But I do like the idea of the downstairs being one type of flooring. It helps with the flow of your house. 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

Ugh, I hate carpet. Talk about dust mites and germs. I can't wait til our kids get old enough that we can take out the carpet in their rooms. We only have carpet on the stairs, upstairs hallway, my son's room, and our girls room. We have hardwood floors in our front living room (which I love and are gorgeous), we have tile in the kitchen and back livingroom, hardwood in our bedroom, travertine in our masterbath (which is also just gorgeous), and I have the fake wood floor up in my office. I hate the fake wood floors!! It is sooo loud. I don't want to hear myself walk. If I drop a pen up there you can hear downstairs it's so loud. I would go with the tile. It's so much easier to clean IMO. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Some others of you don't like laminate as well. Are there other reasons? We, too, are trying to make the decision tile vs. wood (laminate). The laminate I have was in the house when we bought it. It looks cheap and cold to me, not rich and warm like real wood and not durable like tile. We lead a pretty rough lifestyle, going in and out to the garden and kids and dogs coming and going so it has to be tile for me. Wood would be destroyed by all the traffic and playing that goes on here and laminate just sucks! 

Danabug --- 17 years ago -

We are doing our entire house in tile soon, we had the laminate wood, and while it is great for kids, it is ruined in several places because water got in through the back of the house during the hurricane. With tile, if you get water inside all you have to do is clean it, with wood, whether laminate or hard wood, it is ruined and would need to be replaced. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

I hate the fake wood floors!! It is sooo loud. I don't want to hear myself walk. If I drop a pen up there you can hear downstairs it's so loud. YES! Way too loud! We all take our shoes off in the house, mostly for cleanliness but also, if someone forgets, I am about to scream after just a few moments of ordinary walking on this laminate. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

Oh they have slate looking tile you can get now too. Darn Danabug, ya'll just put that wood in too! 

Danabug --- 17 years ago -

Yeah I know, I am glad we at least did the labor ourselves and aren't out that money to :( We will hire out the tile work though, small jobs we can do but to do the whole house and make it flow from room to room, I would rather save my back and knees and have someone else do it! 

picasso1 --- 17 years ago -

We have real wood in our bedroom but took out the carpet and put tile in the rest of the downstairs-love it. With kids and dogs you can't mess it up. 

fishlady --- 17 years ago -

WE put in laminate several years ago in the living room, hallway and bedrooms. I loved it, it looked really nice and has held up really well. We put tile in the bathrooms, kitchen, foyer and dininng room. It has held up good, there are a couple of places where water was left sitting that it messed up a little but I have extra to replace it with, just have not done it yet. A friend just put a terra cotta looking ceramic tile in her entire downstairs and with throw rugs it is beautiful and very "warm" and cozy feeling. If I had it to do over again I would do the warm colored tile. 

ladybeachbum --- 17 years ago -

I just put over 2,000 sq ft of tile at the beach house thinking it would be so much easier. It is good that you can scrub it and clean it but with renters it seems to get really dirty and with only about 6 hours between rentals, I am wishing I stuck to carpet in the living area and wood or fake in the kitchen and dining areas. I had wood strips that I put in 15 years ago that everyone thought was real wood and that was so easy to clean. I almost did the bedrooms in the tile but backed out and I am glad I did. Just be careful which tile and make sure the grout seam is flush with the top of the tile. It looks fantastic, but I can sweep forever and still come up with sand. I might add it is not a smooth surface because with people coming in from the beach, that would have been too slippery. I have to redo the Atascocita house and now I really don't know what I will put in. With my family and dogs maybe the concrete with drain holes so I can just hose it off! LOL 

luv2shop --- 17 years ago -

Tile is way easier to keep up. Laminate/wood floors show every foot print that has ever touched it. It is not near as easy as tile is. I have both and I prefer tile by far. 

Danabug --- 17 years ago -

Just use a darker grout color, makes it easier to keep clean as well because it doesn't stain like a light color would. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Just be careful which tile and make sure the grout seam is flush with the top of the tile. Very good point. I have swept tile floors that have tile with rounded edges and you actually have to sweep with the grooves of the grout lines to get it clean. What a pain! I think the smaller the gap between tiles and the more even the tile and grout, the easier to clean. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

With my family and dogs maybe the concrete with drain holes so I can just hose it off! LOL Wouldn't that really be nice? Just drag the hose in and spray everything down! LOL 

ladybeachbum --- 17 years ago -

Hey, put the hose attachment in a closet and just real it out! You are right about the thin grout lines. My first contractor(I've had a few) did the bathrooms with a small grout line. My second contractor that was to finish said that wouldn't work in a beach house and took out the hall but left the bathrooms. The bathrooms are easy! I just needed to get it done and was willing to listen to the tile guy. Tile can be forever so make sure you love your choice! Oh, and if you drop something glass, oh, my! I dropped a candle in a Mason jar and kept finding glass everywhere! 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Hey, put the hose attachment in a closet and just real it out! Yes, and then a giant blower, maybe through he a/c vents to power dry it all, after! 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

LBB....this is what you need.. We have put a few in in beach houses.. I could not do without it on tile,carpet etc.. http://www.aquaair-wetdry.com/ 

addipie --- 17 years ago -

we did lamininate first...that only lasted 2 1/2 yrs. We tore it up and tiled the entire downstairs (minus the bedroom) 

SueRDH --- 17 years ago -

I voted for tile floors but I would love to do a concrete floor for the downstairs part of our house one day Concrete Floors 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

If you seal your hardwood floors you can clean them with water. I have even used my steam cleaner on them which can be used for sealed hardwood floors. There are a couple of spots where one of the kids dropped/threw a toy from upstairs and it nicked the wood, but we plan to refinsh them in a couple of years. You can also try Bamboo floors. I've never seen them person, but on TV they look really pretty. 

bigla --- 17 years ago -

We have wood everywhere, except bathroom and laundry room...you're welcome to come over and see them... 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

We have hardwood floors in the dining room and living room. We put a ceramic tile in our kitchen and breakfast area when we remodeled. We liked it so much we had it continued into our family room. brick tile to be cleaned and resealed Pictures, Images and Photos We have antiques and a traditional style home so I didn't want something too modern. We have a large oriental style area rug on it. It looks warm and not cold at all. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

It looks similar to a brick floor. We had a dark concrete colored grout put in. : That is beautiful! I was looking for something that looked like cobblestone but am afraid the roundness on the edges would cause dirt to settle there. I would love to have real flagstone but that isn't happening. I need something casual looking, something that will go with antiques, both formal and shabby and also the garden. This looks like it would work well! I am going to check into availability. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground