Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: POLICE DOGS: Are they Officers or just Dogs?

who's talking here?

randyjet 8
needrnr 4
txdaddy 10
Brennan 6
ExLady In Blue 25
pamperedpaws 1
POTUS 16
goatlady 22
jamie 25
MxMike. 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: POLICE DOGS: Are they Officers or just Dogs?

If the police use an attack dog or drug-sniffing dog, and the Suspect strikes, swats, or touches the animal that is attacking him, he will more than likely be charged with Assaulting A Police Officer. People have spent decades in prison for "assaulting" these four-legged supposed Officers of the Law. Do you agree that they should be designated "Police Officers"? I'm curious, because to me, they can't ever be anything more than a trained dog.

Yes, I Consider Them to be Police Officers Vote
 
 53.7% (29)
No, They Are Just Trained Dogs Vote
 
 42.6% (23)
I Don't Care/I Have No Opinion Vote
 
 1.9% (1)
They Are Being Abused by the Police Vote
 
 1.9% (1)
POTUS --- 17 years ago -

If the police use an attack dog or drug-sniffing dog, and the Suspect strikes, swats, or touches the animal that is attacking him, he will more than likely be charged with Assaulting A Police Officer. People have spent decades in prison for "assaulting" these four-legged supposed Officers of the Law. Do you agree that they should be designated "Police Officers"? I'm curious, because to me, they can't ever be anything more than a trained dog. 

MxMike. --- 17 years ago -

POTUS, you are correct. A dog is not and can not be an officer of the law. 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

If a dog is attacking me, I don't care what you call it, it's goin down! 

MxMike. --- 17 years ago -

Right on, goatlady! 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

Right on, goatlady!  :) 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

People have spent decades in prison for "assaulting" these four-legged supposed Officers of the Law. come on...you KNOW you are gonna have to prove this one. please provide some evidence of people (plural) serving decades for assaulting a police dog. more than likely the people committed the assault during another crime and that is what they are serving decades for. do you even believe half the crap you write? i know you love your crusade against police officers but maybe just relax it a bit since cwangel's husband is one and he was assaulted last night. 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

he was assaulted last night. Is he OK? 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

A dog is a dog. But I do think criminals that open fire on a dog are wrong. But if a dog was coming at me with its fangs out.....I'd beat that sucker DOWN. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

i know you love your crusade against police officers but maybe just relax it a bit since cwangel's husband is one and he was assaulted last night. Yea, did they ever update? Potus I for one do not think you have to tone it down just because someone was assaulted last night. Heck a cop assaulted my mom last year and a letter of reprimand was put into his file a year later. 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

i know you love your crusade against police officers but maybe just relax it a bit since cwangel's husband is one and he was assaulted last night. Nothing to do with the topic. And as for proof, do your own research. People go away for this all the time-- yes, they are often convicted of other, often lesser crimes at the same time, but the assault on a police officer charge is what helps put them away. 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

I'm sorry about your mom Jamie! Don't worry, the dirty cop will have to answer for his bull eventually. 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

the dirty cop will have to answer for his bull eventually.  Are you sure about that? 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

People....not all cops are good guys! Like any group there are good and bad. 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

Are you sure about that? Yes, evil people usually end up destroying themselves. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

Don't worry, the dirty cop will have to answer for his bull eventually. A letter of reprimand for assaulting a 50 something year old woman? Come on....wtf is wrong with these ROUGE cops? Why do their fellow cops let them do this? 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

Why do their fellow cops let them do this? Because they don't want to risk pissing off someone they might have to depend on for their life later, it's as simple and sick as that. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

Because they don't want to risk pissing off someone they might have to depend on for their life later, Yea, but the same cop might injury or kill someone in transport or on a scene and all of them "should be held accountable".JMO 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

Yea, but the same cop might injury or kill someone in transport or on a scene and all of them "should be held accountable".JMO They mostly just all cover it up together. That's why they pretty much only get busted when a CITIZEN manages to video tape them. Oh, and BACK ON TOPIC: I'd like to ask the 70% of people who voted Yes... Do you also think that dogs are capable of being Certified Court Judges? If not, please rationally explain the difference. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

And as for proof, do your own research you made the statement which is a complete lie. no worries man...continue your crusade. hope you never need one. 

needrnr --- 17 years ago -

I know of someone who use to be part of the canine unit. That dog was everything to him. Yes if the dog is assaulted they go after the assailant big time as assaulting a police officer. Here is a twist with this person I know... The dog died under his care and there was an investigation against him. Rightfully so, the dog was in his kennel which was properly shaded and the dog had water and everything he needed, but the dog died of heat exhaustion. He and his wife fought many times about the dog, that is why the dog was out in the kennel. What about the horses that they ride are they treated the same as the canine?? 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

I for one do not think you could not have made a truer statement. 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

hope you never need one.  The sad truth is txdaddy, the 2 times I have actually needed one...they weren't there. By the time they showed up the incident was over and we had dealt with it ourselves. I had a cracked out woman in my driveway trying to beat people up and get in our house at 3 am.. the police arrive 30 minutes after we called them. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

People have spent decades in prison for "assaulting" these four-legged supposed Officers of the Law. Do you agree that they should be designated "Police Officers"? I'm curious, because to me, they can't ever be anything more than a trained dog. I think these comments kind of make this a slanted poll, don't you think? As far as them being "officers of the law", yes, they are as a matter of fact. Have you ever served as a police officer or an MP? Police dogs do not go off lead unless they are chasing a criminal and the criminal runs (or is hiding somewhere in the case of a burglary/robbery). The dogs are given instructions by their handlers, a police officer, and the dog follows those commands. The officers/handlers do not let their dogs go at random, nor do they allow them to get blocks ahead of them. I'm with txdaddy, where's your evidence of the "angel" criminals that have spent decades behind bars for assaulting a police dog? 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

Yes, the same goes for police horses. Sorry, Half-Baked comes to mind... the plot revolves around a bunch of stoners trying to bail their friend out of prison after he kills a police horse with sugar snack (the horse was diabetic). 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Why do their fellow cops let them do this? Because they don't want to risk pissing off someone they might have to depend on for their life later, it's as simple and sick as that. Until you walk the walk, I am calling BS on this one. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

yep...these are our youth. yae1 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

As far as them being "officers of the law", yes, they are as a matter of fact. Okay, so once taken off the lease do they have the ability to tell right from wrong? Or do they just go wild on everyone or everything? Can they testify in court against the perp? 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

Blue...did you never work with an officer who was less than "honorable"? I promise you I have met a couple. One wanted to trade me for a "favor" when I was a teen. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

30-18-13. Injury to a police dog, police horse or fire dog; harassment of a police dog, police horse or fire dog. A. As used in this section: (1) "fire dog" means a dog used by a fire department, special fire district or the state fire marshal for the primary purpose of aiding in the detection of flammable materials or the investigation of fires; (2) "police dog" means a dog used by a law enforcement or corrections agency that is specially trained for law enforcement or corrections work in the areas of tracking, suspect apprehension, crowd control or drug or explosives detection; and (3) "police horse" means a horse that is used by a law enforcement or corrections agency for law enforcement or corrections work. B. Injury to a police dog, police horse or fire dog consists of willfully and with intent to injure or prevent the lawful performance of its official duties: (1) striking, beating, kicking, cutting, stabbing, shooting or administering poison or any other harmful substance to a police dog, police horse or fire dog; or (2) throwing or placing an object or substance in a manner that is likely to produce injury to a police dog, police horse or fire dog. C. Whoever commits injury to a police dog, police horse or fire dog when the injury causes the animal minor physical injury or pain is guilty of a petty misdemeanor and shall be sentenced pursuant to the provisions of Section 31-19-1 NMSA 1978. D. Whoever commits injury to a police dog, police horse or fire dog when the injury causes the animal serious physical injury or death or directly causes the destruction of the animal is guilty of a fourth degree felony and shall be sentenced pursuant to the provisions of Section 31-18-15 NMSA 1978. E. A person convicted of injury to a police dog, police horse or fire dog may be ordered to make restitution for the animal's veterinary bills or replacement costs of the animal if it is permanently disabled, killed or destroyed. F. Harassment of a police dog, police horse or fire dog consists of a person willfully and maliciously interfering with or obstructing a police dog, police horse or fire dog by frightening, agitating, harassing or hindering the animal. G. Whoever commits harassment of a police dog, police horse or fire dog is guilty of a misdemeanor and shall be sentenced pursuant to the provisions of Section 31-19-1 NMSA 1978. H. Whoever commits harassment of a police dog, police horse or fire dog that results in bodily injury to a person not an accomplice to the criminal offense is guilty of a misdemeanor and shall be sentenced pursuant to the provisions of Section 31-19-1 NMSA 1978. I. It is an affirmative defense to a prosecution brought pursuant to the provisions of this section that a police dog, police horse or fire dog was not handled in accordance with well-recognized national handling procedures or was handled in a manner contrary to its own department's handling policies and procedures. 

needrnr --- 17 years ago -

I'd like to ask the 70% of people who voted Yes... Do you also think that dogs are capable of being Certified Court Judges? If not, please rationally explain the differenc No I dont think they could serve as judge, but animals sense a lot of things forth coming before humans. Lions can sense sick animals, so they go after those first. If you go to the zoo with a baby stroller with a little kid the lions pander towards you(observed this at zoo in California). Animals can sense fear and can act aggressively towards that. So maybe they cant throw down a gavel, but some animals, dogs can sense if you are up to no good. 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

I think these comments kind of make this a slanted poll, don't you think? I'm pretty sure your side is winning. Do I really have to post cases and articles? People get charged and convicted with this all the time, the case I had in mind was one where it was the guy's 3rd felony (three strikes), so he went away FOR LIFE. Either way, whether they do 20 years or 1 day, the debate remains the same: CAN A DOG BE A POLICE OFFICER? If so, what does that say about police officers? A dog should NOT be relied upon to make rational decisions and use proper discretion in law enforcement and apprehension. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

The sad truth is txdaddy, the 2 times I have actually needed one...they weren't there. By the time they showed up the incident was over and we had dealt with it ourselves. I had a cracked out woman in my driveway trying to beat people up and get in our house at 3 am.. the police arrive 30 minutes after we called them. Goats, unfortunately police officers can't be everywhere all of the time. Sorry this happened to you, but you have to consider, sometimes police officers are directing traffic, helping granny up off of the floor, because they don't want to call for an ambulance, dealing with the shop lifter that tried to steal a package of bologna, or taking care of a traffic accident, which, by the way, is NOT a criminal matter unless someone is high on drugs alcohol or was speeding excessively. MOST accidents are CIVIL matters and it's BS that the police have to go out and handle them to begin with. 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

CAN A DOG BE A POLICE OFFICER? i give you way too much credit. since the dog is already considered an officer of the law...the answer to the question is YES a dog can be. 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

How many police are that busy at 3 am in Kingwood, Blue...on a weeknight? 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

Needrnr....I have been attacked by a dog before(not a police dog) I am fearful of all dogs, so are you saying if I am ever near a scene that I am going to be a target if a police dog gets off the leash? 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

the case I had in mind was one where it was the guy's 3rd felony (three strikes), so he went away FOR LIFE. gee, i feel sorry for his dumb a$$. did he never watch baseball? 3 strikes and your out. when you get two strikes, you make every effort NOT to get the third. i am very happy that trash is behind bars. 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

D. Whoever commits injury to a police dog, police horse or fire dog when the injury causes the animal serious physical injury or death or directly causes the destruction of the animal is guilty of a fourth degree felony and shall be sentenced pursuant to the provisions of Section 31-18-15 NMSA 1978.  

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

People have spent decades in prison for "assaulting" these four-legged supposed Officers of the Law. Either way, whether they do 20 years or 1 day, the debate remains the same potus, the above two quotes are yours. the first one is from the initial post...the 2nd a little further down the page. do you enjoy making outlandish unfounded claims that are completely false only to waffle a little later that the claim did not really matter? 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

i give you way too much credit. since the dog is already considered an officer of the law...the answer to the question is YES a dog can be. The debate is OBVIOUSLY on whether they SHOULD be considered officers of the law. Just because someone decided to make something law doesn't mean it's a just law and realistic. This is like the George Costanza/Moops argument. Are you sure you're older than me? 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Okay, so once taken off the lease do they have the ability to tell right from wrong? Or do they just go wild on everyone or everything? Can they testify in court against the perp? They do not go "wild" off of the lead. They are given commands by their handlers, and the handlers are right behind them giving out commands to the suspect, such as "Police, stop!" It's not like the dogs are quiet and sneak up on the suspects like a cat. If you can't hear a police dog coming, then you must be deaf, in which case I would highly recommend you find another line of "work" (thievery). The dogs are taught to grab and hold. The more the suspect moves, or tries to get away, the more teeth marks he is going to have in him. If a dog has a hold of the suspect, and the suspect stops fighting, then the police dog keeps his hold until the human police officer arrives to cup the suspect. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground