Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

*Experts say Obama should retake the oath

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
whatchamacallit 6
smartypants 3
randyjet 1
Fancy 1
Texas Girl 2
Mabbers 2
Shana Su 1
Sue 1
ghostpost 7
justforfun 1
~sassy~ 1
Setta 5
Forecaster 1
rEVOLution 13
brian* 1
angelbebe77 1
justcat 3
Nightstorm 4
Wilstar77 2
Agent of Change 2
zapper007 1
oneyedman 5
anti-antichange 4
*maryc 2
Ogre1 1
voice of reason 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

One story, Wednesday, January 21, 2009 Should Obama Re-take the Oath... Some respected American legal scholars such as Boston University's Jack Beerman and Georgetown's Jonathan Turley have opined that Barack Obama should re-do the presidential oath, if only to preclude all questions on the validity of the flubbed oath ("will execute the Office of President of the United States faithfully" in lieu of "will faithfully execute the Office of President of the United States") he took in front of Chief Justice Roberts. They may have a point. The issue might not necessarily be whether the oath he took was substantially the same as that prescribed in the U.S. Constitution -- they clearly are. The key question instead would be whether Obama swore to the presidential oath ordained by the Constitution in words that were strung in a particular order. A retaking of the oath would be embarrassing, especially since the Obama administration has cultivated the mien of competence. However, I think it can be spun to his advantage. The oath can be retaken in a low key White House ceremony. The White House can then announce that Obama had decided to retake the oath, consistent with his philosophy of strict adherence to the rule of law, no matter how inconvenient. That decision would advertise the administration's utmost prudence in questions of proceeding in a legally valid manner, and its willingness to promptly correct mistakes when detected since its primary allegiance is to do things correctly without regard to possible pitfalls in public relations. Such a decision would also demonstrate Obama's humility, a trait which he is sometimes accused of lacking. Another take on it, Notebook: Constitutional oath of office gets mangled Words just don’t come easily For a couple of smooth-talking constitutional experts, Chief Justice John Roberts and President Barack Obama had a hard time getting through the constitutional oath of office. There was a false start by Obama, who started to respond before Roberts had completed the first phrase. Obama ended up saying the first two words — “I, Barack” — twice. Then there was an awkward pause after Roberts prompted Obama with these words: “That I will execute the office of president to the United States faithfully.” The chief justice seemed to say “to” rather than “of,” but that was not the main problem. The main problem was that the word “faithfully” had floated upstream in the constitutional text, which actually says this: “That I will faithfully execute the office of president of the United States.” Obama seemed to realize this, pausing quizzically after saying, “that I will execute.” Roberts gave it another try, getting closer but still not quite right with this: “Faithfully the office of president of the United States.” He omitted the word “execute.” Obama now repeated Roberts’ initial error of putting “faithfully” at the end. Starting where he had abruptly paused, he said, “The office of president of the United States faithfully.” From there, smooth sailing. Constitutional law experts agree that the flub is insignificant. Yet two previous presidents — Calvin Coolidge and Chester Arthur — repeated the oath privately because of similar issues. Another, Wednesday, January 21, 2009 Constitutional Scholars: Obama Should Retake Oath A San Francisco Chronicle story today cites several constitutional scholars as saying President Barack Obama should retake his oath of office because of the misstatement of it by Chief Justice John Roberts. "In giving the oath, Roberts misplaced the word "faithfully," at which point Obama paused quizzically. Roberts then corrected himself, but Obama repeated the words as Roberts initially said them." This would not be a first according to the story. Both Presidents Calvin Coolidge and Chester Arthur did so under similar circumstances. Ironically, Chester Arthur was probably the first and only other president until Obama to skirt the constitutional requirement that a president be a natural born citizen. Arthur lied about his date of birth because his father had not yet become a U.S. citizen at the time of his birth, a fundamental requirement for being a natural born citizen. Obama's father was a Kenyan citizen at the time of his birth and all times thereafter. Accordingly, he was born with dual citizenship and fails the natural born citizenship requirement. Obama also later became an Indonesian citizen after he was adopted by his step father, Lolo Soetoro. His name was legally changed to Barry Soetoro. It is unclear if or when his legal name was ever changed back to Barack Hussein Obama. I think the NBC issue is of a little more concern than whether the oath was properly recited word for word, but I'm not a Harvard law graduate like Obama and Roberts so what is my opinion worth. And what is the oath worth if the person reciting it didn't use his actual legal name?  

voice of reason --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

try buying a life Can't afford one now. :) 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

Ok,yes its a little nit picky..but.. Obama actually flubbed it first,by interrupting the Justice on the first line.If you notice,when Biden was sworn in.It was one sentence.I,Joe Biden do solemnly swear... Obama began stating his name,before the Justice finish the sentence..I think that's what threw the whole thing of kilter..Hey...That's my story and I'm sticking to it!! 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

I don't think it's "nitpik'ing" at all. Why should he be allowed to flub something up and not fix it when others weren't?...because he's the first african american to take the oath?...that would be racial and ridiculous! If it should be spoken a certain way and since two others were put in the position of fixing their wrongs, he should as well. Also, it wasn't "obama's" fault...it was the chief's fault for flubbing it in the first place so that should not be an embarrassment to the administration for the repeat. If he screws up...regardless of who caused it or whatever...he should be accountable to fix it...as any other president would have been...period. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Yeah cathou, he interrupted first. Regardless of who said what, it was a bumbled mess. LOL. 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

Ok,yes its a little nit picky..but.. Obama actually flubbed it first,by interrupting the Justice on the first line.If you notice,when Biden was sworn in.It was one sentence.I,Joe Biden do solemnly swear... Obama began stating his name,before the Justice finish the sentence..I think that's what threw the whole thing of kilter..Hey...That's my story and I'm sticking to it!! True...wasn't thinking of it this way...Obama did flub first. They should re-do it for the public and for right's sake IMO...not nitpicking...just how it should be. It threw me off too watching it...and I felt it wasn't spoken right...so who's to stay he took the oath?...if it wasn't spoken right...it wasn't taken! 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Is there any possibility that this was not an accident, leaving a loophole for Po to use as an excuse not to honor his promises and the oath, in general? With Po being such an eloquent speaker, you would think that it wouldn't matter what Judge Roberts said and that he would have just said it correctly, regardless of any possible error on Roberts fault. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

Obama's father was a Kenyan citizen at the time of his birth and all times thereafter. Accordingly, he was born with dual citizenship and fails the natural born citizenship requirement. I am the child of a parent born born abroad and was automatically a dual citizen at the time of my birth. However, because I was born in this country I am a full US citizen. The phrase "natural born Citizen" is not defined anywhere in the Constitution, as is also true with most other constitutional terms. However, case law has interpreted it. I am naturalized in the eye of the law because I did not have to apply for citizenship--I was born a citizen. Same thing for Obama. Find another theory. This one is lame. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

Ha!.... This is the guy who won't even supply a copy of his Birth Cert... Good luck getting him to retake the oath.... 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

Is there any possibility that this was not an accident, leaving a loophole for Po to use as an excuse not to honor his promises and the oath, in general? I thought this as well...since he wasn't willing to put his hand over his heart to honor our flag...maybe this was his way "out" of having to honor his oath?...seems a reach...but then...who knows? 

anti-antichange --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

Ha!.... This is the guy who won't even supply a copy of his Birth Cert... Good luck getting him to retake the oath.... You would think that would be "required" before taking the oath...to supply a BC...he's gotten away with so much...it's amazing...BUT, we must remember...he's the first african american president...so that makes it allllll OK! 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

nitpik nitpik nitpik, try buying a life I knew that would be the response to this news. However, if or when the day comes when Obama breaks that very oath of office and our liberties and constitutional rights are at jeopardy there would be little if any legal recourse for the people in a court of law if the oath Obama took was not recited correctly. Is that a long shot? Of course it is. About as long a shot as Bush or Cheney being brought up on war crimes, lying to the World or otherwise. Is it possible that could happen? Absolutely. How many injustices have our courts allowed in the past because of a simple technicality? 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

Well.I am no Obama supporter...However...I would be more inclined to believe that the chief flubbed it,to embarrass Obama..In case you missed it,neither Biden or Obama voted to confirm him... Not saying I think that really happened,but more likely than the other scenario..Although if you caught the Justice's lips at the luncheon,when he and Obama shook hands,and Obama wagged his finger at him,it appeared the Justice was saying.."my fault" 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

...he's the first african american president... African, American, Malaysian, Hawaiian, Kenyan President. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

moron Squeeze me? You talking about me or Obama? 

Texas Girl --- 17 years ago -

He should have to retake the oath because he didn't do it right the first time. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

BUT, we must remember...he's the first african american president...so that makes it allllll OK! It certainly seems to be foremost in your mind from the constant references your posts have been making lately. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

If he does not agree to retake the oath then I will be left to believe that this mishap was intentional to provide any future attacks by Obama on our Constitution to be legal because of the fact that the oath of office he took was not the Constitutional oath. If he does not agree to retake the oath of office he will be the first U.S. President in History who has misspoken his oath and NOT retaken it stating the correct and Constitutional oath of office. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

BUT, we must remember...he's the first african american president...so that makes it allllll OK! It certainly seems to be foremost in your mind from the constant references your posts have been making lately. I'm not trying to attack you here I don't think it's fair to point out that one person is referencing this when almost every single person on TV, radio, and street corner is referencing the same exact thing. Some proudly, others not so much. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

He should have to retake the oath because he didn't do it right the first time. Yes, I agree...I really makes no difference who's fault is was. It wasn't done correctly and should be redone, in order to keep any problems from popping up later. Of course, I also think Po should just cough up his birth certificate for authentication, but he hasn't done that either. Certainly, if he WANTS to go by the rules and be taken seriously as Americas leader, he should go out of his way to be sure everyone know who and what he is and that he has really been sworn in properly. 

Sue --- 17 years ago -

I thought it was rather ironic, also, that Obama hadn't voted yes for Roberts, and I also wondered if Roberts messed up on purpose as a pay back. 

Setta --- 17 years ago -

It certainly seems to be foremost in your mind from the constant references your posts have been making lately. It does doesn't it?....it just irritates me that he gets to use that as an excuse to get by with things!...I wouldn't care if he were purple...I'd have said..."we must remember he's the first purple president...so that makes it alllll OK!"....please ghostpost..keep in mind...it's "they" that are profound about color...they make it ALl about color and I think that is wrong..regardless of "what" color...it's wrong. It was never spoken...the 43rd "white" president of the U.S....or 42nd and so on. I know this is history and never before has there been a president with any race but white in their blood, BUT, why is that an excuse for all things to just be OK? He's no different than any other president!...and that should speak truckloads that I feel he is the "same" as anyone else...so very non racial if you read me right. I am irritated that everyone else is riding on his race to be "touched" and "moved" and that "change" is come to America ONLY because he's a black president?????....WTH? It should be because he's EXPERIENCED and has KNOW HOW and has a HEART FOR OUR COUNTRY and is QUALIFIED...."not" because he's black...that does not make things change! 

Agent of Change --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

I'm not trying to attack you here I don't think it's fair to point out that one person is referencing this when almost every single person on TV, radio, and street corner is referencing the same exact thing. Some proudly, others not so much. What I find amusing is that people constantly state it doesn't matter to them what color he is, they just don't like him..which is legitimate..but then go on to remark on the fact that he is the first black president so he gets special treatment, blah-blah. I find that a bit ironic. If there are questions about the oath being legal, then by all means, let them have another public ceremony. Judge Roberts will probably find that more embarrassing than Obama. I would prefer that than going through an administration questioning the legitimacy of the office like we did with the Bush/Gore hanging chad fiasco. 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Texas Girl --- 17 years ago -

I thought it was rather ironic, also, that Obama hadn't voted yes for Roberts, and I also wondered if Roberts messed up on purpose as a pay back. Po messed up before Roberts did. I think Po through Roberts off. Po needs to retake the oath regardless of falt. Is he above having to do what is right? 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

Either way it goes, if he does not retake the oath it is going to raise many more questions right along with the whole birth certificate fiasco. Sure seems like he could wrap up all of these problems in about a 15 minute ceremony. Say the oath, and oh, by the way here is my "original" birth certificate. I know that I certainly had to show mine, and have it verified when I joined the military. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Say the oath, and oh, by the way here is my "original" birth certificate. I know that I certainly had to show mine, and have it verified when I joined the military. NOT GONNA HAPPEN! 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

try buying a life Can't afford one now. :) Priceless comeback!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

angelbebe77 --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

justcat --- 17 years ago -

Angel,come back and talk when ya have a clue hon... 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

And when did Science loose it's rightful place? What the hell does that even mean? 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

WHO F'N CARES???? The same people in this country who are concerned that their Constitutional liberties and Freedom are being yanked right out from under them. On the surface no one notices this and that's the plan. Just like boiling a frog, if you throw it into boiling water he'll jump right out, if you slowly warmed the water up he'll allow you to boil him to death. Believe it or not, there are millions of people keeping a close eye on the things that our govt. does. If it were not that big a deal then the past two presidents who misspoke their oaths of office would not have volunteered to retake the oath. It's a very big deal and it has nothing to do with who is taking the oath. It has everything to do with the only legal document that makes America different than any other country. The Constitution of the United States of America. To answer the question WHO F'N CARES???? , I care, if not for myself, than for my children and their children who will have to pay for any mistakes we allow to happen in our life time. 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

And when did Science loose it's rightful place? What the hell does that even mean? I took this as a jab at Christian beliefs being taught as more important than (scientific) the teaching of evolution in it's place. 

anti-antichange --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

The words came out of his mouth, yes he stumbled, but he said them. If I flubbed on my vows, it wouldn't be demanded that I get back up on the alter to do it again....geez. Time to move on. You are not as important as the President. 

anti-antichange --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground