Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Pacifiers?? How old is too old.....

who's talking here?

blessed 1
stampin' gal 3
Denise C 1
teachermom 1
cmi 2
RRay 1
QueenCassie 1
Fancy 1
planemom 1
ambergris 1
MoveIt 2
Deltadawn 2
path 1
Mygirl01 1
irishprincess 2
Mabbers 3
NewMommy 2
SchoolMom 1
Rachel 1
Strait♥lover 1
AIL 1
$AshleyThePrincess$ 2
txdaddy 1
*Vanessa* 1
2girlygirls 2
Flopsy Bunny Boutique 1
RX8LVR 1
~Shannon~ 1
Wanda~more~ 1
chunksNbones 3
Buttercup:) 1
Unichic™ 1
MomTimesFive 3
Evil79 1
Kevin 1
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 1
bckyrdbasic 1
TxSuperMom 1
~Mom2~2gr8girlz&1TWEEN~ 1
ilovepugs 1
Laurabeth 2
Danabug 1
PHSMOMOF2 1
Nickie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

Ok, my kids are WAY past this stage, but I just saw a mom and her kid and had to ask. How old is too old for a pacifier? I'm not talking for a kid that is screaming or in pain or sleeping or napping. I'm talking about a kid happy as can be, getting fast food with mom with a pacifier in her mouth. I have a definitely opinion on this, but I want to know what everyone else says....... 

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

Pacifiers?? How old is too old..... ummmm, the kid that gets picked up from elementary school who then puts a pacifier in his mouth before they leave the parking lot. BTW, I really did see this at my child's school. 

Danabug --- 18 years ago -

Well I broke all three of mine at 11 months old. IMO that is long enough. lol 

~Shannon~ --- 18 years ago -

DD wouldnt give hers up.She been off about 6 months.Maybe less.She is 3.I was hoping she wouldnt start to suck her thumb.I would rather them have the pacifer than the thumb.Thumbs you cant throw away. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

It depends on the kid. I don't think there are definite rules about anything. 

RX8LVR --- 18 years ago -

When we adopted 1st DS, we got him at 15 months... He came with one, but it went in the trash... From what I had heard, he was very addicted, but with everything being so new to him, I figured - out with the old, in with the new.. I don't think he ever missed it. To months later we got 2nd DS (newborn). Oldest DS thought he wanted the pacifier, but he realized he didn't want to be a baby anymore, so he left it alone. Over a year is too old - IMO. 

TxSuperMom --- 18 years ago -

IMO-once they start the sippy cup age they don't need it anymore. It is only meant to be soothing to an infant-not a crutch for a toddler. If your child is old enough to ASK for it, they are TOO old...JMO 

Mygirl01 --- 18 years ago -

My dd was going to K with hers, at least that is what I thought when she was 3 but she eventually gave it up just before turning 4. But after age 3 it was ONLY at bedtime and ONLY nap time at our house not for naptime at MDO. 

*Vanessa* --- 18 years ago -

I can't lie...There have been a few times I have been in a store and saw an child I thought was too old for one. I so badly wanted to run up grab it and run away LOL!!!! I'm not giving an age because what I think dosn't matter it's up to the mom of the child. But if you ever here about a crasy women that stole a kids passy in the store.....IT WAS SOOOO ME! 

Denise C --- 18 years ago -

Mine was about 4. She would put one in her mouth and take one and rub across her nose to go to sleep. Never bothered me. Didn't affect her psychologically or physically so whatever works for people is what works. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 18 years ago -

I think once they are one that pacifer should be in the trash. My kids were a little over one maybe 13 months. Those things are gross after that, they start to stink. 

MoveIt --- 18 years ago -

If your child is old enough to ASK for it, they are TOO old...JMO I tend to agree- I got rid of it before they were 18 mos- told them they were getting to be "big" now and those are for babies..But like Denise says..what ever works for you (except the school age thing...now that's bad.) 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

lol - 0 years old is TOO old!!! neither of mine used them. 

planemom --- 18 years ago -

Once they turn one it's only used at nap and bed time. It disappears all together by two. 

MoveIt --- 18 years ago -

I had a friend whose son drug around one of her (the mom's) nighties as a security blanket until he was 4- it drove me maddddd! edited to say: it was a lacey one, I just thought...Nu uh, this is wrong. lol 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

this kid had to be 3.5-4 that i saw today. i think that is too old to be walking around in public with it. At that age, you can talk, have a conversation, express your needs and opinions. Having the pacifier in just has the kid standing there....... It was a little sad, imo. 

blessed --- 18 years ago -

For me, my cut off is at 15-18 months. It's ridiculous when you see toddlers talking w/that in their mouths. By 10 months we have already narrowed it down to only sucking it when they sleep. There is no "social pacifer sucking" going on. Only for sleep. Then we take it away around 15 months. It's worked perfect everytime for us. They are sooooooooooo busy at that age anyway. 

$AshleyThePrincess$ --- 18 years ago -

3.5-4 Yep too old IMO. But dd never took to one and I will not use any with this one either. My 4 y/o still uses a sippy cup (one of the cheap ones you get that come with a ton of them in a pack) and we have thrown all away but one. And even now I tell her that its dirty (and sometimes she washes it out herself LOL) but its aggravating cause I should have made her stop the sippy cup a long time ago :/ But bottles, I took that away when she was one. She screamed for a few nights but that was it 

Nickie --- 18 years ago -

Mine never took one. Except when she was a lil fussy and even then, it stopped at about 4 months. 

MomTimesFive --- 18 years ago -

Over one year old is too old IMO. My youngest used a pacifier for sleeping only until he was about 15 months old, though. 

MomTimesFive --- 18 years ago -

Mine never took one. Except when she was a lil fussy and even then, it stopped at about 4 months. My oldest spit his pacifier out when he was about 4 months old and never would take it again. 

bckyrdbasic --- 18 years ago -

Once they turn one it's only used at nap and bed time. It disappears all together by two. I aggree! My daughter will be 2 next month. She uses at home for a nap or at night, but then I put it up. She is sick now and it went in the trash today. Wish me luck. LOL 

QueenCassie --- 18 years ago -

I would have agreed with the age of 1 up until I had little DD. She is 3 and still uses it- but for sleeping only. She has to have 3, one for her mouth and one in each hand. She sucks on one, rubs her nose with one, and twirls the other in her fingers. She is a little OCD, and needs consistency (everything has to be the same way all the time or it messes with her) so it has been very difficult to get rid of. And I used to be one of the Moms that would look at 3-4 yr olds with one in the store and think it was ridiculous,lol. Ah,well- I pick my battles, and this is one that is not worth a fight to me :) 

path --- 18 years ago -

Miy kids got rid of it by 3 yrs...one cut it with scissors and the other lost all of them and we didnt replace it 

Laurabeth --- 18 years ago -

How old is too old? 27...yep by 27 they should be just about done! LOL! 

Evil79 --- 18 years ago -

lol - 0 years old is TOO old!!! neither of mine used them. i hear that!!! THats a bad habbit to start! The doctor told my sister the very first time she went for the baby check up he said " get that crap out of their mouth" .. lol 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

My kids were a little over one maybe 13 months. Those things are gross after that, they start to stink. Ewww! Wash them!!! LOL! My ds is over 2 (28 months to be exact haha) and he still has his. But there are a LOT of changes going on in our lives and nothing seems to be settling enough to warrant taking it away. He's like a crack fiend with it hehe. Once you show it to him or mention it, he's all over it. But he is good too. He puts it up without complaint at home (in public different story) Eh. I always said I would take it away at 1. To hell with the rules I say 

2girlygirls --- 18 years ago -

They are actually recommended these days as SIDS prevention. I weaned mine from their paci's when I weaned them from the bottle at age 1. 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Oh mah GAWD...pacifiers. They're evil. Hate 'em, hate 'em, hate 'em. Oldest sucked his thumb, middle didn't need ANYTHING, but Insano...INSANO. The great binky hunt occurs on a nightly basis. He's about to be three and he's TERRIBLE about them. The tantrums. I refuse to let him go into any store or anywhere with that damn binky in his mouth (I just LOVE it when he talks through the bink). We've spent more hours searching for those insidious objects.... ARGH! 

irishprincess --- 18 years ago -

he still has his. But there are a LOT of changes going on in our lives and nothing seems to be settling enough to warrant taking it away. I agree wholeheartedly...my little guy is 18 months...but we are only allowed to have it in our bed for nap and bedtime...he lays it on his pillow when it is time to get up. I figure that it will work itself out. He lays in his bed and goes right to sleep and stays there the whole time...so eh...just not really worth a battle to me...not yet anyway... 

Laurabeth --- 18 years ago -

My son was actually about 18 months old, I told him his binky was for babies and full of germs. He took it out of his mouth and threw it out the open car window while we were driving. I went home and threw out all of them in house.....no problem! 

RRay --- 18 years ago -

You are never too old. I am in my 50's and still like boobies. ;) 

Buttercup:) --- 18 years ago -

Both mine were off right after they turned 2. But my 3 year old found one a couple of months ago and when she popped it in her mouth I realized how much I missed seeing them with a binky in there mouth... She did not take back to it its now for her baby doll. 

irishprincess --- 18 years ago -

laurabeth...I have a baby niece and I was thinking about talking about the big boys don't use paci's argument...but he doesn't use it all night anymore and doesn't wake up if it falls out of his mouth so I think he will give it up pretty easily. 

Unichic™ --- 18 years ago -

I hate to say it, but mine was 2. She was a total booby and paci girl; however, she stopped using the paci during the day at just over a year. She suddenly started getting ear infections and I discovered there was a correlation. Just after she turned 2, and after two HUGE moves from TN to Canada and from Canada back to Texas in a 6 month span, I snipped the tip and it was over just like that. 

Deltadawn --- 18 years ago -

The great binky hunt occurs on a nightly basis. Place a small dish on his dresser in his room, the bink goes in the dish in the morning when he gets up, and he gets it out when he goes to bed. DD had a nuk, I put up a little cup hook and she hung it up when she got up, and took it down when she went to bed. I got tired of looking for the stupid thing. Some suggested the dish idea to me, but thing had a ring, why not hang it up by it? 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Y'all suck. Hahahahahha. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

I took Hunkalicious's away at 4 months...mean mommy. BUT he would cry every time the dang thing fell out of his mouth which was an average of every 8 minutes. It made for a very long night.... I do think 18 months to 2 at the latest. 

NewMommy --- 18 years ago -

Every kid/parent is different. I have a friend who's son is autistic....he is almost 4 and still uses one. So you never know what's really going on when you see a kid with one. He also doesn't talk very much. BUT, when a kid can say "Mom, I need a paci from Wal-Mart" while they have a piece of bubble gum in their mouth....that's too old! LOL And yes, I've seen/heard that! LOL My son had one until 16 months. It was only for bed time and nap time at 1 yr. I was so tired of picking them up at night when he yelled for me. So they went in the trash. He forgot about them after a day or two. 

2girlygirls --- 18 years ago -

Keeping a pacifier in their mouths can keep them from talking too. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground