Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

question for athiests and agnostics

who's talking here?

freshhell 2
CMGs 2
Fancy 1
Rachel 1
Vedette 1
Angela 1
brian* 1
Unichic™ 1
~Songbird~ 8
petoskeypretty 1
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 3
Warren Peace 1
♥kerry♥ 1
jtcitrus 3
AwesomeTattooedDragon 4
JohnLynch 8
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 3
Joe Blow 2
sheddy 3
Nurse Ratched 1
KingOfSomewhereHot 2
JAMS 6
BiteMe 7
butch baby 1
Just Watchin 1
Anna Conda 1
RobWilcox 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

~Songbird~ --- 18 years ago -

Sincere curiosity. I've asked a few of my ag and ath friends this and they all have different answers. What do you believe happens to us after we die? Do you believe people have souls? I'd appreciate just plain answers on topic and if you don't have anything POSITIVE to add, please keep it to yourself. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

I have several friends who are atheists that believe you simply die. One believes in the energy theory that says your energy is transferred into something else- maybe a rebirth. A good friend who is agnostic says he simply does not believe the modern Christian Bible verbatim but instead thinks it is a good parable of stories and a good template in how to live life. He believes Jesus existed but not necessarily as the Messiah. 

~Songbird~ --- 18 years ago -

i've heard all of those as well. i have also heard one believes in reincarnation. 

Angela --- 18 years ago -

I want to see JW's and Freshy's answer to this. If you ever want to honestly get a true answer about this topic then theirs would be the ones that I would feel comfortable knowing was the truth. 

~Songbird~ --- 18 years ago -

one believes in an alternate plane of existance. 

~Songbird~ --- 18 years ago -

that's kind of who i'm hopeing will answer. that and POYBGP too. 

Warren Peace --- 18 years ago -

I've never described myself as either agnostic or atheist....but I do consider myself more spiritual than religious.

So with that qualifier, I'd wager that atheists find the most rational explanation is that life simply expires. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

I believe in ghosts. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 18 years ago -

What do you believe happens to us after we die? Do you believe people have souls? i think that when you die....you die. as far as the soul question goes....i'm on the fence. i don't know really even know if i know what a soul is/does much less if i have one. 

Vedette --- 18 years ago -

Panties, one of my favorite C.S. Lewis quotes is, "You don't have a soul, you are a soul. You have a body." Which for me explains a lot about my beliefs as far as heaven goes. 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

My personal take is "I don't know" The concept of a soul is hard to grasp. It takes a serious leap of faith to believe in something you cannot see, hear, touch, taste, or smell. I don't disparage those that take that leap of faith. But I'm just not there yet. That perfectly describes my feelings. 

~Songbird~ --- 18 years ago -

interesting. thank you poybgp 

~Songbird~ --- 18 years ago -

and CCbC and CMandG'sMom and Warren Peace 

CMGs --- 18 years ago -

that's a nice quote Camille. I do believe that we are a soul, the idea of our soul leaving our bodies, I don't get, but I do believe in the idea that what you do, who you impact, while you are alive, remains long after you are gone. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 18 years ago -

"You don't have a soul, you are a soul. You have a body." interesting....i will have to think on this a while. 

Unichic™ --- 18 years ago -

A good friend who is agnostic says he simply does not believe the modern Christian Bible verbatim but instead thinks it is a good parable of stories and a good template in how to live life. He believes Jesus existed but not necessarily as the Messiah. That's more my thinking too. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 18 years ago -

i honestly don't know where i stand on a lot of things, except that organized religion as a whole and many of its followers do their respective religion a huge disservice when they don't choose their words wisely enough not to sound close minded and condescending. i completely respect their right/choice to believe what they have been taught, but what about those of us who want to make our choices a journey in seeking details and self discovery and the way to be an asset to that journey is not tell us that their way is the only way because the bible tells us so. i've read the bible, more than once at different points in my life. i truthfully got NOTHING from it. not in some great spiritual discovery sense anyway. it didn't strike me as anything more than a story book. it's not for me, but this doesn't mean i can't be good while i'm here. and the more you tell me YOUR way is the ONLY way...the more i realize its not for me. and that's what in MY heart. 

freshhell --- 18 years ago -

I don't believe in an afterlife. The living remember the dead, and in that way the dead continue to influence the living. 

~Songbird~ --- 18 years ago -

I don't believe in an afterlife. The living remember the dead, and in that way the dead continue to influence the living. that is very interesting freshy 

~Songbird~ --- 18 years ago -

i really appreciate all the input. i'm just really curious. i enjoy the diversity and understanding those who believe differently from myself. 

petoskeypretty --- 18 years ago -

JW and freshy....theirs would be the ones that I would feel comfortable knowing was the truth. are you kidding? hmmm 

freshhell --- 18 years ago -

Thanks Songbird for wanting to hear my view. 

Rachel --- 18 years ago -

are you kidding? hmmm She is saying that there's would be clear and concise answers, not any bull. Angela's truth is Jesus Christ. 

♥kerry♥ --- 18 years ago -

are you kidding? hmmm They both seem to be very straight forward and forthright. Whether you agree with them or not, they seem to be respected by many for that trait. 

Joe Blow --- 13 years ago -

0


We have souls. They're call the brain. It dies with us. This is all there is. Enjoy yourself while here. 

BiteMe --- 13 years ago -

We just die. People always ask me if I'm afraid to die since I don't think there is an after life and the answer is....no, I'll be dead, so what do I care? I'm sure the process of dying is not awesome for anyone, regardless of beliefs.


I LOVE the idea of being reincarnated as something else and we just don't remember but that's just as far fetched to me as religion so I don't really believe it. 

Joe Blow --- 13 years ago -

Right, the process of dying isn't fun. Being dead is mindless 

Just Watchin --- 13 years ago -

Why chance it? Why wait until the end and find out that you're dead wrong?

"And as it is appointed unto men once to die, but after this the judgment: So Christ was once offered to bear the sins of many; and unto them that look for him shall he appear the second time without sin unto salvation. (Hebrews 9:27-28)"

What is written in the Bible is occurring write before our eyes via prophesy. There are too many countless events to discount the Bible. The ark has been found, the remains of the walls of Jericho, the remains of Sodom and Gomorrah, etc. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

What do you believe happens to us after we die?

I don't know if something like whatever "I" am will transfer to some alternate existence or not. I am confident that energy is never destroyed only changed. I know every force I've exerted, every unit of atomic energy contained in my cells will transfer to other organisms and/or promulgate through the universe, so my footprint on the universe is eternal.

If there is something more of "me" that transfers. I like the idea of reincarnation.... within that idea, I'm even interested in the notion that it takes the spiritual energy of many creatures to sum to a human (which maybe puts a different spin on the mass extinction we're in the middle of amidst rampant human population growth).


Do you believe people have souls?
"You don't have a soul, you are a soul. You have a body."

this is where I start ask what is meant by "you" (and why I put "me" in quotations above).

I think many people conflate person and personality (just like they confuse Identity with Property). Who I am, my personality is clearly, in part, a function of my physical body: DNA, physical experiences, nutrition, the imprinting of experience on the structure of my brain.

So, when we say that "someone" is going to heaven, do we mean that the imprinting of those physical things transfer with us? that the change in the nature of that ones perception (to the extent that it makes sense to even say 'perception') would not radically change who they were?

or is there some "core-soul" an identity, with properties independent and perhaps interactive with those physical determinants of the thing we refer to as "Me", and only THAT transfers.

with either heaven or reincarnation, would what is transferred be recognizable as "me"?

No clue. but almost anything is possible.

Why chance it? Why wait until the end and find out that you're dead wrong?

Pascal's Wager:
Hedge. Bet on a Religion with dire consequences for not believing, because the consequence of not believing and being wrong are too severe compared to the complete lack of after death consequences of not believing and being right.

not exactly a satisfying basis for faith, and most religions would regard it as insincere, and thus not let you into heaven anyway. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

A good friend who is agnostic says he simply does not believe the modern Christian Bible verbatim but instead thinks it is a good parable of stories and a good template in how to live life. He believes Jesus existed but not necessarily as the Messiah. 

This is what I tend to think too. As far as what happens when you die? Why does anything have to happen when you die. You dead, you get cremated or rot away and are worm food. Such is the circle of life.


Why chance it? Why wait until the end and find out that you're dead wrong?


I hear this from believers quite often. It always confuses me as to if they truly believe or if they think they are just covering they azz in some way. Really sounds insincere and if there is a god and he is all knowing I'm pretty sure he would see through that'll 

KingOfSomewhereHot --- 13 years ago -

When you die, you die.

How about THIS question... why do people believe that SOMETHING happens AFTER death?... What evidence is there to support anything other than just death? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

How about THIS question... why do people believe that SOMETHING happens AFTER death?... What evidence is there to support anything other than just death?


Near death experiences are common, but THIS one trumps them all, not being able to be explained away by brain activity issues. I read it, and I highly recommend it, it's so interesting...And this guy is a neuroscience doc and an unbeliever initially.

"A friend told me about Proof of Heaven several weeks ago after hearing about it on a T.V. talk show. What initially intrigued me about this book was that this Near Death Experience (NDE) account was from a reputable neurosurgeon (Eben Alexander) who had inexplicably contracted an extremely rare form of bacterial meningitis that literally eats the brain, beginning with the neo-cortex. In Alexander’s case, it completely shut down his neo-cortex and sent him into a near brain-dead seven-day coma. Less than one in ten million adults contract bacterial meningitis, and the majority of these die. The few who survive usually remain in a near vegetative state the rest of their life. And never in history, according to this book, has someone remained in a coma for over four days and lived. Alexander came out of his coma after seven days, and he eventually made a full recovery of his mental capacities. His survival is nothing short of miraculous, as Alexander himself testifies. The story of his survival is compelling in and of itself, but what makes Alexander’s NDE particularly compelling is that the neo-cortex is the part of the brain that is responsible for all our thoughts, emotions and everything that makes us distinctly human. Alexander argues that the fact that his neo-cortex was 100% inactivated — a fact that was closely monitored in a hospital setting — means that his experiences while in a coma cannot be explained as a dream or hallucination or any other mental phenomenon. - See more at: http://reknew.org/2012/10/review-of-proof-of-heaven-eben-alexander/#sthash.iJGWizs1.dpuf" 

BiteMe --- 13 years ago -

Near death experiences are common,

Stories like these are nice to hear about and sometimes pretty cool but I don't see how someone's personal account that can't be proven at all is evidence.

As for that specific one, there is SO much that we don't know about the human body and medicine that it's really just an opinion and a guess, in my opinion. 

BiteMe --- 13 years ago -

Why chance it? Why wait until the end and find out that you're dead wrong?

Is that why Christians believe? Just in case? I don't feel like I should follow anything if I don't believe in it wholeheartedly.

If I were religious, I wouldn't feel the need to "prove" there is a god and I wouldn't pretend there was proof. There is no solid, irrefutable evidence. It's called faith for a reason. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

If I were religious, I wouldn't feel the need to "prove" there is a god

yep...you would...that is what religious people do...that's why i'm not a religious person 

Anna Conda --- 13 years ago -

It's called faith for a reason. 

Isn't that reason that it cannot be proven? It is like circular reasoning. The Bible is the word of God because the Bible says so. It must be true that there is a God because the Bible says so. Everything you need to know is right there in that book that was written by God because the Bible says so. Argue against that, nonbelievers! Wrapped up all tight and neat. L Ron Hubbard even followed that model when he created Scientology.

I just do not know anymore. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

Stories like these are nice to hear about and sometimes pretty cool but I don't see how someone's personal account that can't be proven at all is evidence.


My mother's been a nurse for over 40 years, she's says she's seen too many near death experiences to not believe in an afterlife, or in heaven, or in hell. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 13 years ago -

that's a bit of a question for me,too-I accepted Jesus a year ago,but is I still have my doubts about much of the literal bible-I think of most of it as figurative- 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

I think of most of it as figurative- 

so you think Jesus is a liar?...the Word is Jesus...do you really believe that you accepted Jesus if you can't even BELIEVE Him?

tell us something...how do YOU decide what is figurative and what is literal? 

BiteMe --- 13 years ago -

Isn't that reason that it cannot be proven?

Exactly my point. :] 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground