Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Child Abuse?

who's talking here?

Keystone 1
Carla 5
Empty Nest 1
whatchamacallit 1
outermaga 1
~grandma again~ 1
Fiona 2
Lilteapot 3
star7827518 1
Fancy 3
*JR* 1
likeke27 1
ambergris 1
lLackCreativity 2
coach'sgirl 4
Pixel Giggles 1
rose8304 1
cowboyswife 3
BrookleighPhotography 1
Military Mom 2
Clown Vomit 2
Mabbers 5
KWMommaX3..now 4! 1
Rachel 6
txdaddy 11
2girlygirls 1
La_Guerita 1
RX8LVR 8
Wanda~more~ 1
goots1 1
Fin and Feather 1
goodkarma72 1
Adhesive 1
Perfection 1
brian* 1
OH SNAP! 2
petoskeypretty 1
txnkingwood 1
icee2 5
GTV3 2
PHSMOMOF2 1
Big Ben 10
SueRDH 1
scrapfan 1
moltobella 6
Abe Frohman 1
UndercoverMommy 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Child Abuse?

I am a regular here and swore I would never have a alias..but here I am. I need advice. Is it child abuse to throw water in a childs face at the dinner table for pouting? Is it different b/c it is a step dad doing..not biological parent.

Yes. Vote
 
 56.8% (54)
No. Vote
 
 33.7% (32)
Other, please explain. Vote
 
 9.5% (9)
UndercoverMommy --- 18 years ago -

I am a regular here and swore I would never have a alias..but here I am. I need advice. Is it child abuse to throw water in a childs face at the dinner table for pouting? Is it different b/c it is a step dad doing..not biological parent. 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

Is it child abuse to throw water in a childs face at the dinner table for pouting? Seems way over the top for me but I'm just going off what is presented here. 

Keystone --- 18 years ago -

Why not just send them to their room? 

cowboyswife --- 18 years ago -

Hmmm...yeah not a good thing. 

BrookleighPhotography --- 18 years ago -

Seems way over the top for me but I'm just going off what is presented here. Ditto 

*JR* --- 18 years ago -

I think it's really mean and childish. 

~grandma again~ --- 18 years ago -

wouldn't happen but once at my house! 

Wanda~more~ --- 18 years ago -

I think when you harm a child in anger it is abuse. 

ambergris --- 18 years ago -

I don't know that I'd consider it child abuse but it is way over the top and the stepdad handled it very badly. It seems there could have been a more civil way of handling the matter. As a mom I would be pissed and tell him that he needed to tell the child he was sorry for acting that way and explain to the child how they were both wrong in their behaviours. 

Clown Vomit --- 18 years ago -

Is it child abuse to throw a shoe at them at the dinner table? I'm asking for a friend. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

brian - exactly...way over the top...but abuse??? do not use that term lightly i don't think it is...but definitely not appropriate 

scrapfan --- 18 years ago -

Not physical abuse, but could perhaps qualify as mental abuse. It could make a child feel worthless to have water thrown at them--like you spray a cat when it jumps on furniture. It's not some kid-training method. SO over the top! And, it wouldn't matter to me if it was the biological parent or not. The adult is supposed to act as an adult in every situation and model good behavior for the child. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

I don't have the step dad problem, that being said, if my wife and I were divorced, and my kids step dad did that to my child, I would kick his a$$. Verbal discipline I could understand, but I feel that physical discipline by a step-parent is unacceptable. But like I said, my DW and I are happily married and don't have that problem. 

Perfection --- 18 years ago -

Abuse - NO Childish and boorish on behalf of the adult - YES 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

I'm not sure if it's "child abuse" technically, BUT if a grown-up can't control themselves with something like this, what else could happen? Was it controlled or out of anger? Poor kid probably felt so humiliated. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

if my wife and I were divorced, and my kids step dad did that to my child, I would kick his a$$. Verbal discipline I could understand, but I feel that physical discipline by a step-parent is unacceptable do you not see the irony here? 

lLackCreativity --- 18 years ago -

I wouldnt see it as physical abuse. But I would see it as mental and emotional. That strikes me as something you would do to someone to degrade or embarass them. I.E. throwing a drink in a rude guys face. Not exactly done to "teach" anything. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

do you not see the irony here? I don't understand what you mean by that. (not try to be a smartass or anything) 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

I.E. throwing a drink in a rude guys face that's not really abuse...is it? 

Pixel Giggles --- 18 years ago -

wouldn't happen but once at my house! Ditto :-( I am SO sorry that you are going through this right now. IF it were me, I would tell my DH my thoughts on the situation and tell him that IF it ever happened again that he needed to handle it an ADULT way. IF he could not do that OR if it happened again even a similar situation then I would tell him he knows where the door is. YOU are the only person that can protect your child. I do not think it matters if it is a step parent or not. Bottom Line ~ YOU have to be the one to decide what is BEST for you and your child and stick to it NO MATTER WHAT. IF he loves you then he will understand and handle it differently IF it happens to come up again in the future. IF he has to tell him to step out of the room if he cannot handle the situation. Prayers to you and your family, I am SO sorry that you are being faced with this. I know I am only one opinion but hopefully I am able to help some way. IF you need to talk more PLEASE feel free to pm me and I would be happy to be a support system/friend for you while you go through this difficult time. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

If I walk up to you in a restaraunt and throw water in your face, what would you do? 

goots1 --- 18 years ago -

I think that it is disrespectful, childish and uncalled for no matter what the circumstance. That kids food must have gone down like posion! 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

I don't understand what you mean by that. (not try to be a smartass or anything) it's ok to be a samrtass...lol what i was saying is that you say verbal discipline is ok but you would kick the step parents a$$(physical). seems the logic is at odds there. 

whatchamacallit --- 18 years ago -

To me...throwing water in a childs face is similar to slapping their face. Although water may not hurt physically, it is a very hurtful feeling. If others are present the child will feel foolish and embarrased. It is abuse. If I re-married and my husband did this to my child I would be out the door, that being said, I would do the same if it were my childs biological father. The "adult" is acting like a child. I know that children test step parents even more so than their biological parents but this is no way to get a child to trust and respect you. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

If I walk up to you in a restaraunt and throw water in your face, what would you do? hmmmmmmmmm...for no reason? 1. i am not a child...so i would stomp the living sh!t out of you 2. well...that's about it i guess you? 

lLackCreativity --- 18 years ago -

Txdaddy....no. To an adult, in CERTAIN SITUATIONS, I would not consider it abuse. However, to a child. I would consider it a form of mental/emotional abuse. Reason being: an adult is GENERALLY aware of the type of behavior that would result in such an action from someone else. And CHOSE to behave in such a way. For a child I would imagine it was very unexpected, the child did not understand it and it probably did not get the message of whining isn't allowed across in a constructive way that will lead to progressive proper behavior. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

what i was saying is that you say verbal discipline is ok but you would kick the step parents a$$(physical). seems the logic is at odds there. Let me re-word that. If a step parent was to yell at my kid for doing somthing wrong, or verbally discipline him/her, that would be one thing. But the minute that person physically touches my child, thats when I would get physical. Like I ask, If I threw water in your face, I would think that you would probably be ready to whoop my A$$. That child can't really defend himself against an adult, thats when I would step in. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

1. i do not agree with what the adult did. 2. i also do not think it was abuse. it was wrong, and truly "childish"...but i don't think it was abusive. would i do it? no again, abuse is a strong word with legal ramifications. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

again, abuse is a strong word with legal ramifications. I can agree with that, but, think of it like this: How would you feel if that was your kid? 

icee2 --- 18 years ago -

1. i am not a child...so i would stomp the living sh!t out of you so much for no vulgarities. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

But the minute that person physically touches my child, thats when I would get physical. the situation was not physical. But the minute that person physically touches my child again, it was not physical 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

so much for no vulgarities. so sad. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

1. i am not a child...so i would stomp the living sh!t out of you so much for no vulgarities. We are talking hypothetically, not toward each other ;) 

icee2 --- 18 years ago -

We are talking hypothetically, not toward each other ;) well, that makes it okay then. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

We are talking hypothetically, not toward each other ;) big ben - icee2 may have a comprehension problem. or a problem with me. who cares? 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

big ben - icee2 may have a comprehension problem. or a problem with me. who cares? HaHa, I know the real identity of icee 2. She got in trouble last night for vulgarity! 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

How would you feel if that was your kid? hmmmmm...not sure. obviously i would be pissed initially. hopefully, i could control myself and discuss for the benefit of all. of course this is me typing this and not living it 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

HaHa, I know the real identity of icee 2. She got in trouble last night for vulgarity! shocking 

icee2 --- 18 years ago -

She got in trouble last night for vulgarity! no she didn't. i never swore once last night. 

Big Ben --- 18 years ago -

How would you feel if that was your kid? hmmmmm...not sure. obviously i would be pissed initially. hopefully, i could control myself and discuss for the benefit of all. of course this is me typing this and not living it Thats all I was trying to get at. If this was my kid that it happened to, I would see red. If I was in the situation, I too hope that I would be able to control myself. Like I said luckily, I don't have that problem. I just can't picture another man doing somthing like that to my child. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground