Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Violation of speration of Church and State??? Is it????

who's talking here?

smartypants 2
Fallon 5
eterry2 1
My 3 and Me 1
lLackCreativity 1
Deltadawn 3
Going off air 19
eldiablo 2
Bellarue 3
Kingwood_Advisor 68
m•t•v 27
KingTruth 82
mamajulie 1
Itty Bitty Prints 3
Flower Child 2
lemingrebel 6
4zmom 3
haroldoftherocks 51
get_the_lead_out! 6
ghostpost 4
~sassy~ 147
SuperFantastic 13
clever 103
handmedown 2
Forecaster 28
rEVOLution 2
momof5 131
Joan M 5
KU Texan 33
MxMike 1
Lillabeth 15
AngieKaye 3
photo1 1
bruiserbetty* 1
No1Atheist 220
NunyaBizniss 17
KJ 6
No Soup for You 43
poohdale 1
petoskeypretty 34
urphoney 4

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

I am not trying to stir up controversy, but the other night I was a banquet for a high school extra-curricular activty and the sponsor of it said a prayer at it much like the pastor would in church. I go to church, but I was not sure if this was a violation of Church and State. I kinda don't think it should of been said since it is a public school. But that is just my opinion, what is yours?? 

Deltadawn --- 18 years ago -

Off campus and extra-curricular I think it is allowed. 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

I don't just b/c it may be off campus it is still a public school 

clever --- 18 years ago -

I would appreciate the prayer and if I opposed it I would have quietly walked out. Why make a stink, either you like it or you don't. It's all in how you handle the situation. I would do it with respect. 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

It is about how you handle it. But I just felt like that is not the right place for it thats all. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

It is about how you handle it. But I just felt like that is not the right place for it thats all. I understand how you feel but it all comes down to respect for each other. If you didn't like it, you could have slowly walked out. It isn't my place to decide when, where and how prayer is handled but showing respect is. 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

I go to church so it did not bother me. But I was just thinking that (public school) is not the right place to hold prayer. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

I go to church so it did not bother me. But I was just thinking that (public school) is not the right place to hold prayer. That's just the thing. It should be allowed in my opinion. If the school was falling down do you think anyone would care if we said a prayer to stop it? I don't think so. Prayer is like religion, people pick and choose when to use it in my opinion. 

~sassy~ --- 18 years ago -

That's just the thing. It should be allowed in my opinion. If the school was falling down do you think anyone would care if we said a prayer to stop it? I don't think so. Prayer is like religion, people pick and choose when to use it in my opinion. Same here! They prayed before graduation tonight and I was SO pleased! 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

I don't think it should be allowed in public schools just because there are so many different religions and such. It would also violate the seperation of church and state. 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

I don't know if this helps or not, but its about all I could find. Prayer and Public Schools 

Flower Child --- 18 years ago -

Our superintendent (Huffman ISD) prays every year at the first teacher in-service when we are all together. I think it's awesome and I respect his boldness to do so in public school with public school teachers :) 

clever --- 18 years ago -

Our superintendent (Huffman ISD) prays every year at the first teacher in-service when we are all together. I think it's awesome and I respect his boldness to do so in public school with public school teachers :) I respect the fact that he does it too. I wish more people would say, enough is enough. 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

From reading the web site that No1Atheist posted a link to, what that school sponsor did was unconstitutional. 

Deltadawn --- 18 years ago -

dh is a teacher and says it makes a difference if it a "school sanctioned" event or not. 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

dh is a teacher and says it makes a difference if it a "school sanctioned" event or not. that is what i was trying to find, because i thought that was the case. and just to be clear, i don't really care either way. i would be/am respectful of any situation like that. 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

what do you mean by school sanctioned? 

clever --- 18 years ago -

From reading the web site that No1Atheist posted a link to, what that school sponsor did was unconstitutional. What is the next step? Suing someone for saying a prayer. I would stand up for that person any day. People should stop trying to please everyone and say this is how it's going to be and deal with it. To many people are selfish and only want it their way. Time to stop all of that in my opinion. 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

It is called seperation of church and state. 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

People should stop trying to please everyone and say this is how it's going to be and deal with it. To many people are selfish and only want it their way. who do you suggest decides such a thing? 

clever --- 18 years ago -

who do you suggest decides such a thing? That I'm not sure of but you see what allowing everyone to complain accomplishes. Nothing. People complain about anything and everything but if a decision was made and we had no choice things would change. I don't care if it's the government or we take a vote and go with the majority. 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

They prayed before graduation tonight That is also unconstitutional 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

who do you suggest decides such a thing? and i am not trying to wage war, but it comes down to a simple case of whose rights supercede someone else's. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

and i am not trying to wage war, but it comes down to a simple case of whose rights supercede someone else's. So far the Atheist have ruled school prayer in my opinion. They didn't want it and it was taken out of school. It was taken out long before we had so many different religions here too. Maybe everything goes full circle and it will return. I can always hope. 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

and for Christians, i would think anyway, they would find it particularly offensive if prayer was "allowed", but it was a Islamic prayer for example. 

Deltadawn --- 18 years ago -

If the event is specifically sponsored by the school and, or the participants are representing the school, then it is a school sanctioned event. The sponsor of an event is normally a staff member at the school, or another school employee. If such is the case, for that person to have led the prayer is a huge no-no. The first amendment is only worded to prevent the government from establishing any specific church. The concept of separation of church and state is one that has evolved over time, and is subject to change with the changing membership of the Supreme Court. Madison, the author of the Bill of Rights had no intention of banning religion from government. The above was written by my dh. I my first response for some reason I was thinking of a "booster" rather than a "sponsor". If a booster held a party for team members at their home, then the prayer would be ok. 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

i agree completely that it is a tough situation, because Christians (or any religion) have rights too. but i wonder if sometimes its not lost that the government is trying to be as impartial as it can be, like when your kids are little and they are fighting and you say, fine, if you are going to fight, nobody gets it!! i don't know, just a thought. 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

they would find it particularly offensive if prayer was "allowed", but it was a Islamic prayer for example. Exactly, by praying in schools just does not work since there are so many different religions out there. 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

Exactly, by praying in schools just does not work since there are so many different religions out there. you can't please all the people all the time. so this is where ethics come into play, and the phrase for the good of the people is fitting, because it refers to all people. the system will NEVER be unflawed. 

lLackCreativity --- 18 years ago -

Praying in school, no problem. IMO its not really hurting anyone, maybe just annoying some. But all people are always annoyed by something somewhere some how. What I always wonder about is: would people be upset if a non-Christian prayer was said at a school event? Would a big fuss be made about that? That question is one of the ones I try to not let myself ask myself. We can't get to a good answer on it. 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

would people be upset if a non-Christian prayer was said at a school event? do you mean, a non-denominational prayer? sadly, i think you answered you your own question when you said all people are always annoyed by something somewhere some how. with all this being said, i would like to point out that although i am an atheist, i am not hardcore where my kids are concerned. i do not get all hyped up if my kids hear prayer, or want to participate, they have actually attended many church functions with their friends. i think that faith is personal, even for children. 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

Praying in school, no problem. I disagree. For example, at that banquet I know of someone that was there who is Muslim. The prayer that was said was a Christian prayer (which I had no problem with since I am a Christian, just the timiing. I support the seperation of church and state), but it made me wander how they felt. For that prayer to be said one religion was chosen over another which is a violation of the first ammendment. 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

For that prayer to be said one religion was chosen over another and there enlies the problem. 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

and there enlies the problem. exactly 

poohdale --- 18 years ago -

You know the way things are going these days pray on brother we could all use it. 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

You know the way things are going these days pray on brother we could all use it. lol, funny. sadly it might be true. 

clever --- 18 years ago -

Praying in school, no problem. I disagree. For example, at that banquet I know of someone that was there who is Muslim. The prayer that was said was a Christian prayer (which I had no problem with since I am a Christian, just the timiing. I support the seperation of church and state), but it made me wander how they felt. For that prayer to be said one religion was chosen over another which is a violation of the first ammendment. You just answered that question yourself. If I was in there country and they had prayer I would respect it. Would I agree ,no but I would respect their culture. The same goes for everywhere. We aren't all going to agree so we give up prayers because people come from other countries and we would rather offend our self than them. There is something wrong with that picture. 

No Soup for You --- 18 years ago -

The first amendment technically does not call for separation of church and state. It states that "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof . . ." The problem in public schools, I believe, is related to an issue already mentioned in this thread: That there are many religions. 

No1Atheist --- 18 years ago -

We aren't all going to agree so we give up prayers because people come from other countries and we would rather offend our self than them. here is another spin on this though...and please just hear me out, my liberal self is screaming, lol. not all people of another religion are from other countries. many are born here, right here on our soil. another example...what if decided tomorrow to convert to Islam as my chosen faith (not going to happen, but...)i was born here. i have lived here my whole life. i pay taxes, and lots of them, here. where is my right to NOT be offended? 

KU Texan --- 18 years ago -

There is no state religion. I respect others beliefs and I would hope they would respect mine, but like I said there are so many religions and saying a prayer for which ever religion is a violation of the first amendement. 

Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics
religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground