Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Married Couples Sleeping in Seperate Bedrooms

who's talking here?

mugglemom 1
whatchamacallit 1
stampin' gal 5
Sweetie Pie 1
Tedelady 2
JDB2 1
~grandma again~ 1
Lilteapot 1
Fallon 7
QueenCassie 3
mikesgal 1
crazyfun2baround 15
kjones0125 1
gking 1
cowboyswife 2
OhCheesecake! 2
TXamanda 1
eldiablo 2
Mom's Taxi Service 1
addipie 1
HuntersMommy♥ 1
Sue 1
ghostpost 1
~Shannon~ 1
clever 3
Forecaster 2
Wickenburg 4
brian* 1
KWmomof4 1
sterling 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Married Couples Sleeping in Seperate Bedrooms

A discussion the other night got me to thinking about this. Do you think that a married couple who have children, that are truly trying to save their marriage, could do so by sleeping in separate bedrooms? If yes, why? If no, why? I keep thinking that financially it would help both of them out. Emotionally it might put enough distance to straighten their hearts and minds out. However, wanted input from KU!

Yes, I think it work. Vote
 
 31.7% (19)
No, it couldn't possibly work Vote
 
 15.0% (9)
Maybe, depending on the couple Vote
 
 53.3% (32)
crazyfun2baround --- 18 years ago -

A discussion the other night got me to thinking about this. Do you think that a married couple who have children, that are truly trying to save their marriage, could do so by sleeping in separate bedrooms? If yes, why? If no, why? I keep thinking that financially it would help both of them out. Emotionally it might put enough distance to straighten their hearts and minds out. However, wanted input from KU!  

cowboyswife --- 18 years ago -

Why not? I think if you are TRYING to save your marraige, why not try and see how it would work? It never hurts and at least you know you TRIED. 

mugglemom --- 18 years ago -

growing up, my parents were repeatedly separating and getting back together. they also did the separate sleeping arrangement as well. we were young, but caught on quickly. if anyone is deciding on doing this, be ready to answer questions from children. 

addipie --- 18 years ago -

I don't know but I think it would be very confusing for the children 

~grandma again~ --- 18 years ago -

I must be dumber than a stump. how can sleeping in seperate bedrooms help a marriage financially? how can you save a marriage by having seperate bedrooms? the bedroom should be your recluse spot to get away from the world and have time together. 

crazyfun2baround --- 18 years ago -

I don't know if I would repeatedly seperate and get back together. However, if the kids have been told that mom and dad were trying their best to make it work, I wonder how it would. I wonder if couples tried this, if the divorce rate would go down. I know financially it would help out both sides. I wonder if emotionally it would give each side enough seperation that they could work it out. Just makes me wonder. 

Lilteapot --- 18 years ago -

I think if two people came to this agrement there must be something still there for them, and it is certainly worth a try. I think you should try everything you can before ending a marraige, especially if there are children, jmo 

QueenCassie --- 18 years ago -

I know financially it would help out both sides. So you are talking about separating, just living in different rooms/sharing the house instead of one person moving out? 

crazyfun2baround --- 18 years ago -

the bedroom should be your recluse spot to get away from the world and have time together. But, what if it wasn't. What if that is where the majority of stress is at? Sleeping in separate rooms would help because you both would still be responsible for the reg bills. You wouldn't have the 2 rents/2 of everything bills. If that makes sense. Could sleeping in separate rooms help give them the time out that was needed, instead of total seperation? 

KWmomof4 --- 18 years ago -

how can sleeping in seperate bedrooms help a marriage financially? ok i thought the same thing...but it helped me and my hubby. "Trial Separation" even in the same house if you will... 

JDB2 --- 18 years ago -

oops...I get it now. 

crazyfun2baround --- 18 years ago -

So you are talking about seperating, just living in different rooms/sharing the house instead of one person moving out? correct. I was wondering would it be too much like a roomate situation, or would it be more like back to square one dating? 

brian* --- 18 years ago -

I think anything is worth a try. It's better than just leaving. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

or would it be more like back to square one dating? maybe that would help? try to go back to what was magical at the beginning and see if it is still there. And yes....i do believe you can sleep in separate rooms and still make things work. I'm not sure if doing that FOREVER is a good idea, but certainly for a bit I can't see to much harm. Eliminate stress.....if the bedroom is your stress point (where you fight the most or whatever), then maybe eliminate that and go from there. :) 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

I predict you know the answer already. 

Tedelady --- 18 years ago -

No, I think it is a good idea. The kids already know that there are issues, why compound it with two separate homes. Both parents are still around for stability for the children, but have a little breathing room between themselves while they sort out their feelings, situation, and see if they are able to find a resolution. I think it would show the kids that it is not about them but more about mom and dad needing their "space" without running away or cutting them off entirely. JMHO 

mikesgal --- 18 years ago -

IMO children see how their parents interact during waking hours and don't think much about where they sleep at night. Parents who are at each others throats on a daily basis is worse than parents who maintain a decent relationship while sleeping in seperate rooms. Again, JMO 

crazyfun2baround --- 18 years ago -

I'm not sure if doing that FOREVER is a good idea, I agree with that! However, what kind of time restriction would there be? Is 6mths to long, or not enough? I know back in the day it would be okay for a man and woman not only sleep seperately, but, seperate rooms as well. However, it seems odd in this day and age. 

whatchamacallit --- 18 years ago -

No, I think it is a good idea. The kids already know that there are issues, why compound it with two separate homes. Both parents are still around for stability for the children, but have a little breathing room between themselves while they sort out their feelings, situation, and see if they are able to find a resolution. I think it would show the kids that it is not about them but more about mom and dad needing their "space" without running away or cutting them off entirely. JMHO Exactly what I think. And as for kids asking questions...just tell them you need some space. That is the truth and you don't have to answer everything they ask in detail. 

Tedelady --- 18 years ago -

Except that I know folks that do it due to snoring issues, sleep apnea (sp?) and misc other health issues. This is just a mental health issue since you are driving each other crazy. Take the pressure off and try to meet on neutral ground. 

Forecaster --- 18 years ago -

I predict there is no time limit. I further predict spouse 1 and spouse 2 must take said time to become serious in trying to resolve the issues of marriage. My predictions say you will be dating semi-monthly and fall passionately in love again soon. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

I agree with that! However, what kind of time restriction would there be i think you would know.......i certainly don't think 6 months is unreasonable. If every couple took 6 months to try to work things out, find solutions, spend time solving problems, there would be a LOT less divorce (IMO!) 

gking --- 18 years ago -

In my experience - the only way it has a chance of working is if both wish it to work. If either is against it, then the separate room accommodations will only worsen things. One may get the mistaken idea that the other actually prefers it that way, while the other may only foster more and more resentment as progress is stalemated and the "distance" widens. 

Wickenburg --- 18 years ago -

I keep thinking that financially it would help both of them out. Emotionally it might put enough distance to straighten their hearts and minds out. These two statements are utterly ridiculous. "Financially helpful"? HOW? Sleeping seperately to "straighten their hearts out"??? So if I were to work out a communication problem with my spouse I should not speak to him/her? No wonder people have problems. 

QueenCassie --- 18 years ago -

These two statements are utterly ridiculous. "Financially helpful"? HOW? As an alternative to one of them actually moving out- incurring 2 rents notes,2 sets of household bills,etc. 

crazyfun2baround --- 18 years ago -

Okay, financially, you wouldn't have 2 rents, 2 water bills, 2 etc..Also, wouldn't have the daycare needs, the after school care, etc. That is what I mean financially. If the communication has stopped and the bedroom is a fighting arena, do you think separate rooms wouldn't help to put a stop to the fighting and maybe, just maybe, get them to start talking again? gking-I agree that I think it would have to be an agreement on both sides or it wouldn't work. Too many emotions involved not to have both sides agree. 

eldiablo --- 18 years ago -

In my experience - the only way it has a chance of working is if both wish it to work Exactly right! Just to be clear: Divorce is worse than separation to different residences. Separation is worse than separate bedrooms. The goal for both people should be to fix the big problems so that they can share their lives fully. If either is not committed to fixing things, then moving to separate bedrooms is not going to help. This arrangement is better than just jumping out of the marriage because it buys some time for both people to cool off and consider what is best for them and their family. 

sterling --- 18 years ago -

I love this topic because I sleep in the guest bedroom while hubby sleeps in the master bedroom. Bottom line-he works days-I work nights-we wake each other up morning and night-he snores-I watch tv until three am. We love our arrangement because guess what-two days off and he is in my room! lol! Privacy all the way plus the excitement of knowing those two days are great! So try two days together and the rest alone if you have the extra bedroom. Again-I only have one kid at home a senior in high school and he knows the situation-happpy marriage-24 yrs-just different work schedules! It works if you work it! 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

If the communication has stopped and the bedroom is a fighting arena, do you think separate rooms wouldn't help to put a stop to the fighting and maybe, just maybe, get them to start talking again? yes. that is my answer. :) 

QueenCassie --- 18 years ago -

If the communication has stopped and the bedroom is a fighting arena, do you think separate rooms wouldn't help to put a stop to the fighting and maybe, just maybe, get them to start talking again? yes. that is my answer. :) Ditto. 

Wickenburg --- 18 years ago -

I don't think seperate bedrooms would be the answer to fighting. A good dose of marriage counseling would. Worked for US and we've never slept apart. But that would require WORK and many people are too put out to actually WORK on their marriage when all the answers to life's problems are online. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

wickenburg, i totally understand what you are saying, but the couple in question ARE working on things.....counseling, etc. And, one thing any decent counselor will tell you is go to the SOURCE of your problem and go from there. If being in the bedroom together is a big factor in the fighting, then it makes sense to try to eliminate that factor (at least for now). 

crazyfun2baround --- 18 years ago -

that would require WORK Figured since most know that I am talking about my dh and I, I would let you know that dh and I have worked at this. It is going on 11 years. However, we are truly struggling right now. We are both trying to figure out how to make it work, not only for us, but, for our kids as well. We have done the counseling as you suggested. I am very happy that it has worked for you two. It doesn't always work for everyone else. You should consider yourself lucky and hold on tight. If I didn't want to WORK as you put it, this thread would not have been started. 

Wickenburg --- 18 years ago -

If I didn't want to WORK as you put it, this thread would not have been started. I'm not singling you out. I was making a broad statement. :) 

clever --- 18 years ago -

Do what is in your heart. If it doesn't bother you or dh then don't worry what others think. I am always comfortable with what I think and not how others feel. 

ghostpost --- 18 years ago -

Whatever works to save a marriage...try everything. 

crazyfun2baround --- 18 years ago -

I'm not singling you out. I was making a broad statement. :) Sorry..just a wee bit touchy!! Please keep in mind, all that read this, my dh is working on this as well. That is why I am looking at all options. The thing that I ask, is those that pray, please pray that God gives us both the directions we need to take. I fully believe that God put my dh in my path of life. He and I have two wonderful kids that I would not change for the world. There are just some major issues that we for some reason can't work out that we need help figuring out! 

Sweetie Pie --- 18 years ago -

My poor kids think EVERYBODY's parents go to bed in the same room and then the Daddy wakes up on the sofa because he snores so loud. Has nothing to do with good or bad marriage, just a good nights sleep! 

clever --- 18 years ago -

Is it a sex thing or communication thing? You don't have to answer but usually it's about sex. I know, none of my business. Sorry. 

Wickenburg --- 18 years ago -

I'm not singling you out. I was making a broad statement. :) Sorry..just a wee bit touchy!! And I'm a bit old fashioned enough to believe that people should not let the sun go down on their anger. It's in the Bible. But I guess I won't open up THAT can of worms here... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground