Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is this out of line?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
stampin' gal 1
Sweetie Pie 1
ilovemykids1030 1
Fallon 1
Fancy 1
Danabug(BCM) 4
Sandyr9111 1
likeke27 2
brsgj 1
kjones0125 4
MXFamily 1
MoveIt 1
Mabbers 3
Cicero 1
$AshleyThePrincess$ 1
txdaddy 7
MeAndMyGang 2
Brennan 1
Happy_Monkeys 3
4zmom 2
Sue 1
ghostpost 2
chunksNbones 1
chipmunk 1
3monkeysmomma 1
notreallyhere 1
londonbridge 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

londonbridge --- 18 years ago -

My DD's preschool teacher called to discuss her progress. My DD is a strong-willed child and the teacher does not seem to know what to do with her. (Surely, mine can't be the first??) Amongst other comments, she said, "I think she needs more discipline in the home." Is this out of line? I just can't imagine my other DD's elementary school teacher making this comment. Or should I blow it off since it's only from a preschool teacher? 

chunksNbones --- 18 years ago -

I don't think that sounds out of line at all... 

Danabug(BCM) --- 18 years ago -

I don't think it is out of line either. It sounds to me, like she is trying to work with you concerning your daughter. 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

i think it is out of line, but then again i would have told her she might want to look for a new career after her comment of "the teacher does not seem to know what to do with her". 

brsgj --- 18 years ago -

imo it is, you can discipline a child at home all day long doesn mean that they will behave once out of your site. jmo 

ilovemykids1030 --- 18 years ago -

I think she needs more discipline in the home." is that true? is that why ur offended? not talking crap, but i know ive been called out on something before and i was insulted cause it was true.. 

$AshleyThePrincess$ --- 18 years ago -

imo it is, you can discipline a child at home all day long doesn mean that they will behave once out of your site. jmo thats exactly right. My child acts completely different when shes at home and when shes at my moms. When she's at my moms shes fine (my mom also lets her do almost anything she wants but wont let her get away with everything.. she makes her pick up etc) But when she gets home OMG- Very whiny and Im just about the same as my mom.. the problem is is her dad... oh yea daddys little girl BIG TIME. Well I take that back... she calls him "Stinky Ol' Dad" lol 

likeke27 --- 18 years ago -

she calls him "Stinky Ol' Dad" lol last night at wal-mart i had to spank my 6 year on the butt in front of a lot of people, than the young which is 2 said " stupid dad". how mean. 

londonbridge --- 18 years ago -

ilove...No, I don't think it's true. We do not have a problem with the crying like she is having at school. She did cry a lot and throw fits when she was 2 and 3. But she is 4-1/2 now and doesn't do that any more at home or on play dates or in public. Thanks for your opinions, but I'm just having a hard time taking this teacher's opinion who only sees my daughter for a total of 9 hours a week and does not have any sort of degree in early child development. 

Brennan --- 18 years ago -

unless this teacher is in your home then i feel like it was out of line. i hate when teachersjudge wiht out knowing what does happen at home 

Danabug(BCM) --- 18 years ago -

Maybe the way she acts at school is different, if that is the case, then maybe what the teacher meant was that you can work together on how to handle the situation. Maybe if she is being that bad at school there should be consequences at home. Did you ask her to clarify what she meant? 

Sue --- 18 years ago -

Maybe she does need more discipline at home or consistent discipline, but then again maybe the child and the teacher have a conflict. My almost 4 year old granddaughter has a teacher in daycare that she doesn't get along with. Sometimes children act one way at home and another way in a different setting or with a different adult. I've had two strong willed children but at school they were not a problem. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

i really do not think it is out of line. you entrusted this person with your child knowing she had no degree so why would that matter now? i think maybe she was reaching out to you. maybe could have phrased it better but i would prefer the teachers be honest with me about my children than not. are there specific actions in school that caused the teacher to say this? should there be a talk with your daughter and the teacher to reinforce the idea that you and her are on the same page about behavior? i dunno...may not make much sense. but dismissing what she says because she does not have an early childhood development degree seems a bit crass 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

I'd ask her to explain herself. Discipline? What kind? Do I need to stick to my diet better to show my kid discipline? Do I need to write, "I will not yell at my kids!" 100 times? 

londonbridge --- 18 years ago -

I told her we have adequate discipline here and she wanted to know what kind. I told her naughty chair and spanking. She said "OK" 

Mabbers --- 18 years ago -

Then I'd tell her you'd welcome any suggestions she may have. 

notreallyhere --- 18 years ago -

Thanks for your opinions, but I'm just having a hard time taking this teacher's opinion who only sees my daughter for a total of 9 hours a week and does not have any sort of degree in early child development. Not being harsh here but how many parents have a degree in child development? That could be the problem. We all need more parenting skills. 

londonbridge --- 18 years ago -

I guess what I was getting at is that I LIVE with my DD. This teacher sees her for a few hours a week. She obviously doesn't know her like I do OR knows what goes on in our house. I know I don't have a degree in early childhood dev., but I would be more apt to take someone's advice who did. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 18 years ago -

Well if that is the case you shouldn't take ours, most of us are without a degree as well. 

londonbridge --- 18 years ago -

No, but a lot of you ARE parents. I'm not asking your opinion of my DD, I'm asking what you think about the teacher's comment. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 18 years ago -

I think she is reaching out to work with you. Is it possible that your dd acts bad at school even if she doesn't at home? 

Fallon --- 18 years ago -

Good point bcm. My youngest is butt wild at home. But he knows if he ever gets in trouble at school, that it will be far worse when he gets home. I do not under any circumstances tolerate bad behavior from my boys at school, or in public in general. They know this one rule, if they don't know the others. 

Cicero --- 18 years ago -

Amongst other comments, she said, "I think she needs more discipline in the home." Is this out of line? I would've asked her what qualifications she had to make that evaluation. 

Happy_Monkeys --- 18 years ago -

What are the problems that are happening at preschool? Is your daughter not respecting the teacher? Is she hitting or screaming?? Maybe you could arrange with the school to monitor your child's behavior, without your child knowing you are there. Then you could see if indeed the teacher is not qualified and address that with the director. Or you can see which behavior/behaviors your child is exhibiting and address those issues while she is still so young. She just may not understand and be confused. That's simple to fix now, but very hard to stop later as she gets older. IMO, respect of elders and authority figures is of the utmost importance. I would definitely want to know if my child was being disrespectful and not minding at preschool so I could nip that behavior in the bud, before it becomes habitual and harmful to her developing to her full potential. To answer your question, no, I don't think the teacher was out of line. She could have worded her concern much differently instead of being accusatory and immediately putting you on the defensive. I don't think that was her plan. I think her main concern is your daughter, but she is obviously not a tactfully speaking person. Sit down and talk with the teacher and you will be able to determine if she is qualified to guide your daughter. If she's not, then pull your daughter out of her class. 

3monkeysmomma --- 18 years ago -

Well, not knowing her or how your DD is really acting in class, it is so hard to know. Does your preschool not have two teachers in the room so that you could get the other teacher's opinion? I don't know if you are interested, but all three of my kids have gone to Atascocita Pres. preschool and MDO programs. All of the teachers are certified and absolutely wonderful. They are also inexpensive. Full disclosure - I'm a member, we joined after we had our oldest there for a year and got to know the people. Anyway, kid issues are always difficult. Good Luck! 

MoveIt --- 18 years ago -

I agree that the teacher is just looking for solutions. Maybe she should have "asked" if you had similar issues with her at home...but people don't always say thing the right way. Is your DD difficult at home? It is unacceptable to disrupt class or be disrespectful to your teachers, Or any adult as far as I am concerned. 

londonbridge --- 18 years ago -

She is not hitting or doing anything to any of the other kids or screaming. She is crying basically when she doesn't get her way. The examples the teacher gave me was when they transition from one activity to another and my DD doesn't want to stop doing whatever she's doing. Second example is if they are choosing chairs when sitting in a circle and my DD doesn't get to sit by her girlfriends. 

Fancy --- 18 years ago -

I guess what I was getting at is that I LIVE with my DD. This teacher sees her for a few hours a week. She obviously doesn't know her like I do OR knows what goes on in our house. During a parent-teacher conference, back when my son was in preschool, his teacher described how my son behaved at school. I thought she must have confused my kid with someone else's, cuz what she described, was not the child I know. It was all good, but not at all the way my child acted around here. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

The examples the teacher gave me was when they transition from one activity to another and my DD doesn't want to stop doing whatever she's doing. Second example is if they are choosing chairs when sitting in a circle and my DD doesn't get to sit by her girlfriends. sounds like she might be throwing tantrums when she does not get her way. sounds like to me some home training would be helpful. why would you not agree? imagine the place if every child did this every time during these activities... 

londonbridge --- 18 years ago -

Training at home how? If we are not having these issues at home? 

Sweetie Pie --- 18 years ago -

I think you are both seeing the same thing it's just you see it as "strong willed" which implies a positive aspect and her teacher sees it as not listening/not obeying which may indicate more discipline is needed at home. This is the age they have to learn to do those things, listen to the teacher, respect the group, etc. Perhaps the teacher is just trying to get her ready for Kindergarden. Eventually other kids start to notice these things too and then it gets worse. In MY children, when a teacher tells me something about their behavior at school I usually take it seriously because my kids can be difficult at home but are usually much better behaved at school or with others, so if somebody else is noticing something I try to look at it objectively. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

Training at home how? If we are not having these issues at home? "if you do not behave at school, then _____________ will happen" maybe she is looking for you to reinforce the concepts presented there. 

Happy_Monkeys --- 18 years ago -

"if you do not behave at school, then _____________ will happen" Txdaddy, that's a simple and wonderful tactic. I will put that in my disciplinary arsenal for my little one. 

kjones0125 --- 18 years ago -

where does she go to school, if you don't mind me asking? you can send it via PM. i heard the same thing from a teacher and just wondering... 

Sandyr9111 --- 18 years ago -

imo it is, you can discipline a child at home all day long doesn mean that they will behave once out of your site. jmo Ditto. Disciplining mine dont help a bit. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

Txdaddy, that's a simple and wonderful tactic. I will put that in my disciplinary arsenal for my little one. lol...not sure if that is being sarcastic or not, but thanks. i just think the teacher was asking for help. maybe just used the wrong words. 

Happy_Monkeys --- 18 years ago -

lol...not sure if that is being sarcastic or not, but thanks No sarcasm, I think it's a great tactic! I usually overthink issues and make it too complicated. Your statement simply and directly lets the kid know what's going to happen if they misbehave. Now the consistency of the follow through on the discipline is the important step. If we don't follow through they know they can manipulate us, even those little bitty kiddoes can figure that one out! Right?? 

kjones0125 --- 18 years ago -

We went through something very similar with our strong-willed, determined little DS. He is generally a very sweet, loving child but once he went from MDO to preschool at this place he used to be, he was a different child. He would kick, scream, throw things, hit kids, spit on the teachers, etc. The teacher even said the same thing to me "He needs discipline at home" and all that. OK fine - we tried it their way and it just escalated and got worse. I mean, we tried stickers, good and bad consequences etc. Finally had a meeting with the director and I was almost in tears by the time it was all said and done. Basically said my child was the only one who ever acted like this (that was a BIG lie), that he needs to learn how to treat others, and all this garbage. Made it seem like he was learning these bad behaviors at home and bringing them to their school. Oh hell no. At any rate, he started at a new place in early December last year and within the first week, he was back to his happy, loving self. He's learned more where he is now that he did the 3 months of preschool at the other place. GRRR - gets me all worked up again just thinking about it. I think some places, sometimes private ones, have a certain idea of how kids are supposed to act. They have to march this way, eat that way, everyone has to look the same, act the same, etc. and my son just wasn't having any of it at all. There was no room whatsoever for the individuality of the child to come out. 

txdaddy --- 18 years ago -

He would kick, scream, throw things, hit kids, spit on the teachers, etc so this was all acceptable to you since his individuality was being suppressed? maybe i am confusing what you are saying. 

kjones0125 --- 18 years ago -

no, no, no... I knew someone would think that. I think because they didn't care about him at all, because he stood up for himself, and didn't take crap off anyone, they didn't like him and therefore, treated him that way. I did not think it was OK for him to behave like that. He was disciplined at home for 3 months every single day for his bad behavior at school. He's a smart kid. He understands about consequences but it was evident to me that he wasn't happy there and no matter what we did at home, he didn't want to go to school. I figured if after 3 months, he didn't get the hang of the routine, then something must be wrong there, not with him or me. Does that make sense now? Plus the fact that he's in a different school and we do not have any of these issues at all. To me, that shows it was the school and teachers, and their lack of caring, that caused some of his problems. Plus the fact that there were 2 other boys who hit and bit him on a regular basis. He just wasn't going to sit there and take it. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground