Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

College football- what a mess!!

who's talking here?

Melanie 15
stampin' gal 2
Sweetie Pie 1
bbjones 3
likeke27 3
coach'sgirl 5
CyberSage 5
Tyrus 1
Pet Lover 1
Cajunmom 1
Brian 7
Itty Bitty Prints 1
Flower Child 1
BMD004 3
chappers 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Brian --- 18 years ago -

So tonight Pitt upsets West Virginia. Currently Oklahoma is beating Missouri by 11. Leaves Ohio State with 1 loss at number 3 now potentially number 1. Who plays them for the national title? 2 loss Oklahoma which will have beaten the current number 1? What about 1 loss Kansas who lost to Missouri last week? Maybe undefeated Hawaii who plays in a second tier conference? Possibly #4 Georgia who isn't even in their conference championship game! That game was won by 2 loss LSU. What about them? If this mess doesn't beg for a playoff system, I don't know what does. Been a great, crazy season but it's going to be fouled up by this silly BCS nonsense. 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

BCS is BS anyway. I can't believe WVA lost! OMG!! Mizzou is losing too. Yikes! I can't stand OS. Yuck!! 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

Ohio State- Georgia??? Are they REALLY the best 2 teams in college football? Wouldn't a playoff right about now be MUCH more fun and truly decide who is the best? 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

Yup! The BCS stinks. I don't know why there isn't a true playoff. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

you know, my hubby just finished watching one of the games (no clue which one) and came out saying the same exact thing! He says it is just insane....... 

coach'sgirl --- 18 years ago -

Geaux Tigers!!! 

coach'sgirl --- 18 years ago -

you know, my hubby just finished watching one of the games (no clue which one) and came out saying the same exact thing! He says it is just insane....... We too are having this discussion as we finish watching the OU game. Sounds like a huge mess to me too. I just hope they find a way to get LSU in there. 

stampin' gal --- 18 years ago -

I just hope they find a way to get LSU in there. ah, see we are NOT lsu fans in this house, so I think my hubby is getting a little evil satisfaction out of the whole mess. 

coach'sgirl --- 18 years ago -

My hubby says there will never be a play off system because of the money and the bowl games. The school Presidents will never vote for it. The plus 1 game could be an answer but there would still be a controversy between #4 and #5. What say you Brian? (I don't know about all this stuff, just typing for him as I tell him what you all are saying) 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

My dh said too that there will never be a playoff game but to me we'll never really know who #1 is. The BCS never matches all the other polls. 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

BTW-we ARE LSU fans here! Geaux Tigers!! 

Tyrus --- 18 years ago -

You are right Brian. It is a mess. I don't think that any of the teams deserve to be number one. They have all choked when the title is on the line. 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

Here is what I think: 8 team playoff. Seed them #1 thru #8 based on the polls. 1 plays 8, 2 plays 7, so on. The current bowl sites host the games with a rotating title game to the different sites selected. 8 teams play 1 game, 4 teams play 2 games, and 2 teams play 3 games. Think the drama will build for that?? As it stands here would be the matchups: #1 Ohio State versus #8 West Virginia- Cotton Bowl #2 Georgia vs. #7 Missouri- Gator Bowl #3 LSU vs. #6 Oklahoma (ooooh)- Peach Bowl #4 Kansas vs. #5 USC- Orange Bowl 2nd round Ohio State vs USC- Fiesta Bowl Georgia vs. Oklahoma- Sugar Bowl Championship USC vs. Oklahoma- Rose Bowl Oklahoma national champs That sounds MUCH more fun than this crap we are stuck with now. 

Sweetie Pie --- 18 years ago -

BRIAN: My Dh is watching ESPN now and basically yelling out everything you've posted about this. I was wondering if he was on KU reading your posts, LOL! 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

Oklahoma national champs NOT! You are sure assuming WAY too much in your playoffs Brian. USC would lose to Kansas LSU would beat Oklahoma Os vs LSU Tigers are national champs! Way better scenario, don't ya think? 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

Melanie, I just think settling it on the field is MUCH better than you and I discussing who might win. That's why I hate the BCS. Let 'em play for the championship, not debate for it. 

coach'sgirl --- 18 years ago -

Georgia vs. Oklahoma- Sugar Bowl Championship USC vs. Oklahoma- Rose Bowl Oklahoma national champs You need to replace Oklahoma with LSU and that sounds good to me. But hubby says Saturday football would turn in to Sunday football where it doesn't mean a whole lot when you lose. You have to win every Saturday to make it to the Championship, that is what is great about college football. But then again....you didn't have to this year. 

coach'sgirl --- 18 years ago -

Oklahoma national champs NOT! You are sure assuming WAY too much in your playoffs Brian. USC would lose to Kansas LSU would beat Oklahoma Os vs LSU Tigers are national champs! Way better scenario, don't ya think? I like your scenario. 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

But then again....you didn't have to this year. Exactly the reason it should be settled by football players and not sportswriters. Or biased commentators (me included) on a message board. 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

I like your scenario. Thanks coach's girl! Just kidding with ya Brian. : ) 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

Just a SLIGHT bias towards the Tigers, Mel? So Ohio State- LSU for you? I'd love to see them both play their way there. The conference championship games need to be discontinued too. Just play the regular season. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

In my opinion, they should take the two teams with one loss, Kansas and Ohio State, and have them play for the championship. LSU, Georgia, Oklahoma, etc. have lost two games and should not be playing for the title. The only caveat would be is if they wanted to give Hawaii a shot since they have not lost. I know that their schedule is not as tough as some of the others, but they played the schedule that was put in front of them and took care of business. If they gave Hawaii a shot, then it should be Kansas verses Hawaii since Kansas lost to a higher ranked team than Ohio State did. 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

Just a SLIGHT bias towards the Tigers, Mel? Who me? LOL! 

Brian --- 18 years ago -

Very good points, bb. I'm with you. I'm intrigued by Hawaii and their gunslinger style. You are right that Kansas lost to a higher ranked team than OSU too. I personally believe Ohio State would beat either KU or Hawaii, but I'm just a guy pecking at a keyboard. The players on the field can decide it better than us. Personally I think the 2 best teams TODAY are probably LSU and Oklahoma with Georgia and USC close behind. 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

Ohio State is not & they'll probably be playing in the big game. 

bbjones --- 18 years ago -

Personally I think the 2 best teams TODAY are probably LSU and Oklahoma with I disagree about LSU. They had too many close games. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

I don't understand why Kansas is excluded. Also, couldn't we hve a split national championship. When Ohio State gets crushed, the team that does it will be the BCS champ. But couldn't the AP or CNN poll name another champ, like what happened with LSU/USC? 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

The only one that makes a difference is the BCS. BCS poll is what they go by not the coaches or Ap or Harris polls. 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

...But they DID have a split national championship in the BCS era. So, that would make you wrong...right? 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

It was in 2003 - I just googled it. 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

LSU was #1 in the BCS poll in 2003. Period! The BCS poll rules. It doesn't make a difference if USC was #1 in the other polls. USC fans claim a share of that title, not LSU fans. 

Flower Child --- 18 years ago -

I really don't know much about what you all are talking about......but GO BUCKEYES!!!!! (I'm a Buckeye :)))) 

Itty Bitty Prints --- 18 years ago -

I think too much emphasis is put on the records of a team--2 loss LSU or 2 loss OK. There has to be more of a factor built in for strength of schedule. Like Hawaii, what the heck is Hawaii doing in the upper rankings? Makes no sense. They may be undefeated, but how can you compare them to Ohio State, LSU, or Oklahoma? These rankings are like comparing apples and oranges. 

BMD004 --- 18 years ago -

bb, that doesn't really make much sense. You can't just take the teams with the better records. You have to figure in the teams played. I think a 2 loss SEC team is a lot better than a 1 loss kansas (who only played 2 oponents with a winning record). Look at LSU's schedule. They have played 6 ranked oponents and beaten 5. Their only two losses were both in triple overtime. They have overcome an astounding amount of injuries. Look who has been injured this year for them, and they are still competing at a top level. Tennessee was basically beaten by LSU's second string today. By the time the national championship comes, most of their players should be close to full strength, so they should play one hell of a game. Kansas didn't win their conference, and neither did Georgia, so they are out. Oklahoma was behind lsu before they won the big 12 championship, and lsu won their conference also, so I don't think oklahoma would pass up lsu. virginia tech was ahead of lsu and won their conference, but virginia tech and LSU has the same record, and LSU beat them this year by 41 points. So I think they pass them. So, in my opinion, it will be Ohio State and LSU for the championship. I'd like to see how Ohio State fares against a smashmouth SEC team again this year.. it also makes it more exciting for an LSU fan, since the game is in New Orleans this year. I think it would be a good title game. Most people in the nation agree that LSU and Ohio State are the two best teams right now, acording to polls on cbs, fox, etc. 

BMD004 --- 18 years ago -

...But they DID have a split national championship in the BCS era. So, that would make you wrong...right? That's true.. but I don't consider that a national championship by the ap poll.. because they didn't play the top team. They played the #3 or #4 team (can't remember which). So yes, they won the game, but it wasn't a national championship game... 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

LSU was #1 in the BCS poll in 2003. Period! The BCS poll rules. It doesn't make a difference if USC was #1 in the other polls. USC fans claim a share of that title, not LSU fans. Well, I didn't know I was dealing with a biased coon***. I can't understand why so many people love LSU - if they play their cards right, someday they may rise to the level of TSU academically. Of course that was a split national championship. Get a clue. The whole season is what matters - not just the ranking of the bowl opponent. 

Pet Lover --- 18 years ago -

So sad about WVU. My mom's church family won't be the same in Parkersburg this morning...LOL! 

CyberSage --- 18 years ago -

...and the refs did everything they could to give the game to WVU. But it wasn't meant to be. Every team has major flaws. LSU has Les Miles. Ohio Sate is a decent team in a lousy conference. USC lost at home to a Stanford team that would finish about 8th in C-USA. Georgia had a blow-out loss. WVU was crummy without Pat White. OU lost to Colorado...... 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

Well, I didn't know I was dealing with a biased coon***. You're not! I'm not from the south but I did live in Baton Rouge & my brother did go to LSU. Temper, temper CyberSage. : ) LSU & the SEC has always had great teams to watch. They play with heart & guts & I just plain love them! JMO. 

Melanie --- 18 years ago -

So yes, they won the game, but it wasn't a national championship game. Well said! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground