Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Would you be upset? Football advice...

who's talking here?

Melanie 2
Paige 1
outermaga 1
FirePrincess 1
JDB2 1
ilovemykids1030 9
And1 1
txwareagle 2
txsweetpotato 1
Sandyr9111 1
Key 1
maverick 1
CyberSage 4
txmommy 8
Allipop Designs 2
missym 1
LAXmom 1
jenAlynn 4
Cicero 1
KWMommaX3..now 4! 1
Katie D. 2
Jacko16 4
★ † 12 Stones † ★ 1
txdaddy 5
haroldoftherocks 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

txmommy --- 19 years ago -

I will try and not let this be to long..My ds is a 7 yr old that has only played one other year along with several other boys on the team. There are several boys that are 8 almost 9 that have played three seasons. The coachs tonight were doing a drill were there were two boys up they would fumble the ball and whichever boy didn't get it the other had to do 10 up downs ( jogging in place then fall to the ground). Well by the time they would get done doing there 10 it was there turn to do the ball again and if they missed they were doing 10 more. Over and over t his was going on. Finally a dad got mad and voiced his opinion. It did stir a big issue up because the coach told the dad if he didn't like how he did practice to take his kid and leave. Well of course when you pay 285 bucks that doesn't solve the problem. my dh was at a meeting and wasn't able to be there but now that I have told him he is HOT. Do we have a reason to be upset or should we just let it go? We totally agree in discpline and all but now alot of the boys we played with last yr are not wanting to play because they don't think there is good as the other boys and just say they can't do it..Whats ya'lls opinin?? 

FirePrincess --- 19 years ago -

7 years old? I'd be upset. That sounds like something that could be done to junior high or high school kids, but not 7-9 year olds. 

Paige --- 19 years ago -

I think the coach definitely responded wrong to the dad, however, the dad totally put him on the spot. I am sure of he would have approached him w/out confronting him loudly in front of his team he would have listened. 

txmommy --- 19 years ago -

I agree the dad did do it the wrong way but after the dad did express his concern with a nice voice about it the coach continued to tell him if he didn't like it then take your son home. How about lets work on this? Things could have been done in a better mannner in my opinion... 

ilovemykids1030 --- 19 years ago -

i wouldnt be upset..thats football. we were at football practice today also, and they dont play around! doing the up/downs give him initutive to try harder. 

Jacko16 --- 19 years ago -

my boyfriend has been playing football since he was 6, he is now been playing for college. I told him about this just now and the first thing he said was " how old are they?" than he said" up and downs are u kdding me, maybe some jump n jacks, but never up and downs" "this should be fun for them it is not a career." he has coached this age before and he is amazed, he has never hurd of the young of an age doing up and downs, and the only reason he would have them do up and downs would be for punishment, not because they did not get the ball. He laughed and said i am from west texas were football is Hudge, and they never had us doing up and downs at that age 

txmommy --- 19 years ago -

i wouldnt be upset..thats football. we were at football practice today also, and they dont play around! doing the up/downs give him initutive to try harder. YES true it is football and yes they need to work and try hard but why push them so hard the first hour of practice so by the end of practice they are so dang tired they are not working at all... 

txmommy --- 19 years ago -

jack...exactly these boys are just learning i will sure hate to see what "punishment" holds for them if this isn't even punishment supposedly teaching them to try harder to get the ball... 

Jacko16 --- 19 years ago -

right, i dont know. maybe the coach just thinks they are bigger and stornger than they really are. but that should be stuff they do in like middle school age, not lil guys age 

txmommy --- 19 years ago -

i guess so ...hopefully the yr will get better..off to a rough start.. 

JDB2 --- 19 years ago -

*deleted because I am not nice sometimes* Sorry! 

Jacko16 --- 19 years ago -

hope so too... that will make or break some kids that are going to want to play. maybe the coach does not understand that. if some of these boys arent having fun they are not going to want to come back the next time 

Jacko16 --- 19 years ago -

jdb- sorry didnt see i spelled it worng i was trying to talk on the phone watch tv and type and the same time. too many football games, not enough class! and yea, lost of football players are smart!!! 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

These kids should be learning the game by playing it. Football sucks bad enough when you get older; maybe this is a blessing to get your ds into an actual sport where they play real games and do stuff besides eating stickers for hours at a time. 

Melanie --- 19 years ago -

What league is this? My dh played football through college & this just isn't right for 7-9 yeear olds. I love football & I know this is "the" sport for Texas but I would call the coach or go beyond him to have my questions answered & my ds enjoy a sport. 

txmommy --- 19 years ago -

we loved it last yr and had a great coach..he had his hard moments but nothing like this..i want him to enjoy it but hell not be ran to death over not beating the other guy to the ball you know.. 

LAXmom --- 19 years ago -

Is this Kingwood Footbal league? 

Katie D. --- 19 years ago -

My son's on Sophmore league in KFL too (based on the price you paid, I'm assuming you're KFL...it's crazy!). Our coach had the kids doing the same drill a few weeks ago, but they had to run to a tree and back if they fumbled. Actually, he makes them to that anytime they fumble...not just in that drill. Anyway, it sounds like your coach was going overboard. I'd be most upset about his reaction though. If a parent expresses concern, he should be open to listen to it. I sure hope he didn't react that way in front of the kids or I'd really be mad. 

txdaddy --- 19 years ago -

hmmmmm, there is a fine line between expressing displeasure with how a coach handles practice and calling the coach out in front of everyone. maybe the drill was a little excessive, maybe not. but the dad should have waited and called the coach or talked to him after practice...unless the child is in danger of being hurt, then say what you need outside of practice without the kids around. the coach definitely should not have told the dad that. he should have hanndled the situation better as well. after being put on the spot in front of everyone, he reacted poorly. i would guess because there is a certain need for being the authority figure in coaching simply because the is part of the role. you should call the coach and talk to him. why file a complaint with the league? you have a concern but the problem is not worthy of filing a complaint. the coach was well within his right to have them do up downs. it is a regular tool used, and in fact is not bad for conditioning. however, talking to the coach and giving him the opportunity to either apologize for his response or explain himself seems to me to be a better, more adult thing to do, than running to the "boss" and telling. again, it does not appear any kids were hurt. the kids will have to learn that any sport will have practices that are not always "fun". as long as they are not put in danger, i don't have a problem with them. 

Key --- 19 years ago -

If you don't like the way practice is ran then you should sign up to coach next year. 

ilovemykids1030 --- 19 years ago -

my son is 5 and hes exhausted after practice. we practice 4 days a week, 2 1/2 hours a day. in august. in texas! thats ALOT and its hotter than hell!!! all the boys work their butts off. they run if they arent paying attention. they run if they are goofing off. they run for pretty much any reason. we do EMC, and we paid 85 bucks (gotta love that!). the coach is my cousin, so im not the least bit shy about saying what needs to be said. but im very quickly coming to understand that football is football. if u dont want them to work hard and be screamed at, u should put them at the YMCA where everyone has to hug and sing 'the barney song' after every game. im not trying to be rude..i just reread this and it sounded bitchy. lol. i think i would let it go..or maybe you should call the coach and touch base on the issue. let him know ur concerned about it. and i would ask/encourage other parents to do the same..after hours obviously. that one dad did it wrong. he should have waited. 

jenAlynn --- 19 years ago -

i just reread this and it sounded bitchy. txmommy is anything but! she is always fair about things. i know they work them and thats fine, but it can get too intense for 7 yr olds! i have heard the coaches out there and they do need to back off some! i woul let someone know so they can monitor it and make sure he isnt one of those that takes it too far =) 

ilovemykids1030 --- 19 years ago -

The leagues need to grow out of the redneck mentality yeah, ours is totally redneck! pop-warner system i think this is what we are using. lol. 

jenAlynn --- 19 years ago -

The leagues need to grow out of the redneck mentality and develop standards for coaching with age-tiered benchmarks. there, that is exactly how it is wher txmommy is talking about! LOL.....very well said steve, i agree 

ilovemykids1030 --- 19 years ago -

txmommy is anything but! she is always fair about things. oh no, i meant MY post sounded bitchy, not txmommys! 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

I think she meant she sounded bi$%#y not txmommy 

jenAlynn --- 19 years ago -

oh no, i meant MY post sounded bitchy, not txmommys! lol, K =) 

ilovemykids1030 --- 19 years ago -

i think of it like this. we live in tx. its august. we put our kids in TACKLE football. its not gonna be easy. 

ilovemykids1030 --- 19 years ago -

and i also think like this...would we rather our sons be 'those kids' that are coming up doing absolutely NOTHING outside? they have gameboys, xboxs, playstations and computers. no sports. no physical activities. nada. i know there is an even medium.. 

txwareagle --- 19 years ago -

TxMommy. Call the coach and express your concerns. If you dont, you will not get any piece of mind. If you dont get a satisfactory response, call the commissioner for your age group. When we played in the KFL they were open to parent concerns. Just a note for parents: Try not to do this stuff during or immediately followng practice. Coaches are micro-managers by nature and they will respond negatively to being openly questioned during an activity, esp football coaches. If you are concerned for your kids safety, go get him and leave. Personal opinion, up-downs like any activity are fine for 7-8 year olds. hundreds of up downs are not. 

txdaddy --- 19 years ago -

There is a difference in yelling and yelling-at Of course there is, but if you want your son wants to sing Barney and get hugs…don’t play football. The nature of the sport is not conducive to that atmosphere. There will be yelling in football practice. a bone jarring joint stressing exercise that has been proven to do damage to developing anatomies. Not really sure what you are referring to here. Is there evidence to say this? Besides the anecdotal evidence you provide below? I would guess there is more “bone jarring” in the actual game due to the contact than any drill whereby no one hits another player. The leagues need to grow out of the redneck mentality and develop standards for coaching with age-tiered benchmarks. If by “redneck” you mean antiquated, what “old” style is still being used? I work with a man whos pro football career was ruined because he came through the pop-warner system and had no cartilage in his knees by the time he was 22. An anecdotal situation. Who is to say it was pop warner that actually made the knee bad? If so, why are there pop warner leagues if this is actual evidence that playing in them WILL CAUSE the knees to deteriorate? Everyone’s body is different, but to my knowledge, to date…there has not been evidence that specifically links pop warner football participation to this condition. i would also guess he spent more time in high school football than pop warner. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

5 years old, 4 practices per week, for 2 1/2 hours per day? You made a poor parenting decision. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

Don't worry - I've made some too. 

txdaddy --- 19 years ago -

The facts are that improper weight training and high impact exercise has been shown to be extremely detrimental to children whose bones and cartilage are still growing. 100% completely agree. at that age, probably should not be lifting weight at all as their growth plates (i think that is what they are called)are still developing. Study after study has been done to prove that Football and the way it is coached on the lower levels is dangerous to the long term health of the ones who played it. The "suck it up, shake it off and play hurt" attitude is also very unhealthy. Rare is it that a little league coach has a degree in Anatomy, Physiology, Developmental Growth or has specialized in Sports Medicine. That does not mean that they aren't great guys but it does almost insist that the league use resources to develop guidelines. agree to an extent. i am not sure how one would quantify this type of tests. did the kids undergo MRI's (etc) before playing as a baseline? were they tested immediately again after the season. i just am not so sure i could jump on this theory without more knowledge of the actual tests. the "suck it up" thing has diminished IMO. i think today's coaches are more aware of actual injuries than 10 years back or so. unfortunately, with the little league coaching situation being voluntary and doubtful that there would be any compensation ever, i don't think we will ever see professional medical people within the coaching ranks. not sure if they would be able to even "coach" if they did. it would be nice, but since it is voluntary, i doubt it will happen. The "redneck mentality" I referred to was not one of antiquated methods. It is one of thinking that one will accomplish character building by raising ones voice "at a child." If this was HS maybe, college OK. Heavens these are 7-10 years olds. i think, as you mention below, there are different types of coaches. i have always been one to believe that you figure out how to motivate each person, then do it. if it takes yelling, fine...as long as it sticks to football related stuff, if it takes quiet encouragement...that is fine as well. both coach types have been successful (in cyclical fashion it seems) so it is difficult to say one is better than the other. i too have had my share of yellers and quiet talkers...i found that both probably accomplished what they wanted for me and do not "favor" one over the other. as long as the kid is not purposely placed in harms way...i don't have a problem with either type. 

txdaddy --- 19 years ago -

5 years old, 4 practices per week, for 2 1/2 hours per day? You made a poor parenting decision. wow cyber...that's a little rough don't you think? i mean, it is her child. 

maverick --- 19 years ago -

It is obvious this coach is one of those losers that thinks he is a tough guy. He will take kids who love football and make them hate it. Football is a tough sport, but it is supposed to be fun, especially at this age. I would go to the league and try to get this guy replaced. There is no excuse for him to respond in this way. Make sure they know he was telling your husband to take your son and leave. I dont think I would take that quietly from a punk like that. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

wow cyber...that's a little rough don't you think? i mean, it is her child. Maybe, but it's no worse than many decisons parents make, such as: 1) Giving children too much sugar and setting them up for a life of poor eating habits. 2) Placing them in daycare all week long. 3) Blaming everybody BUT the child when the child makes a mistake. 4) Allowing the child to speak rudely to parents, teachers, siblings... 5) Not giving the child any spiritual training. 6) Watching too much tv. Yeah, this football thing is a minor mistake and nothing to obsess over, but a mistake nonetheless. It is not possible for the child to see anything other than football as the most important thing in his life. Does any parent really want that for a 5 year old? By the way - I think it was wrong to call out the coach during practice. imo, that was a typical Kingwood thing to do. 

KWMommaX3..now 4! --- 19 years ago -

2) Placing them in daycare all week long. yes, that is what every parents longs to do......that was totally uncalled for. who in the hell do you think you are making a statement like that? 

Allipop Designs --- 19 years ago -

Well i do know about this situation and the whole thing was handled wrong. I do undertsand where the parents are coming from, but I also know that these men out there coaching are the only ones that have stepped up to the plate to coach. Now do they need to treat the boys like this, no! I'm sure at times the parents can be very over whelming too. In this case I do believe that all parents with any concern about these coaches should come to the board meeting and voice their concern. That is what the board is there for. 

Melanie --- 19 years ago -

Some parents have to put their kids in daycare for the week. That really wasn't the right thing to say Cyber. You're going to get a lot of flack from that one. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground