Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

tithe

who's talking here?

blessed 1
Thoughtful 5
MissT 3
Mary C 7
Fallon 7
bbjones 11
My 3 and Me 4
55andunder 1
amb07 1
Going off air 2
biker-mom 1
2coolboyz 24
Cindi 1
Duke 1
Bethiepoo 1
Proud Parents of a Punkin' 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

Where in the bible does it say it is a requirement to tithe? Yes, I know all the scripture about a cheerfull giver, and that they would bring their best fruits to the alter, but then they would enjoy the bounty themselves. Plus, where is it a "commandment" per say? Why do churches preach that if you give you will be blessed in return - am i tithing to buy God's blessing? Before I get slammed, we do tithe and give offerings because it is money to run the church and pay it's staff so that they can do ministry full time - it is just one of those questions that may or may not have an answer. Paul in the bible worked so he wouldn't be a burden on the church, why do our preachers/ministers feel they are above this? I get bigger churches becuase they have so many people to contend with and get ready for, but what about small churches? 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

I know in the past bb gave some good information on this, give him a while and he will give you infor I bet. I tithe too, but some things are nuts. I tithe to people like the Brittany Fund, and Oh Cheesecake too. I mean there are time I'd rather give in these situations than to a church's building fund. I know I may get slammed for that, but often times I see churches doing some real boneheaded things, they expect the congregation to pay for. 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

Malachi 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

I tithe too, but some things are nuts. I tithe to people like the Brittany Fund, and Oh Cheesecake too. I mean there are time I'd rather give in these situations than to a church's building fund. I know I may get slammed for that, but often times I see churches doing some real boneheaded things, they expect the congregation to pay for. See, I think that if you are blessing people...aren't you still blessing God? I agree, we have debated on giving more to KSBJ and the International Justice Mission - that is just where are heart is right now. Wouldn't God be blessed if a %5 tithe was given with a cheerful heart, rather than the standard %10 tithe feeling forced? 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

"Bring ye all the tithes into the storehouse" (Malachi 3:10), yes, but that seems to be the only real basis...even that is thin. When God seems to really care about an issue, it is backed up several times and it is not a gray area... 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

"Bring the whole tithe into the storehouse, so that there may be food in My house, and test Me now in this," says the LORD of hosts, "if I will not open for you the windows of heaven and pour out for you a blessing until it overflows." The general thinking these days is to tithe where you receive. Anything over that (to other endeavors) is offerings. We have had church members want to give us their tithe, but we always refuse it... it needs to go to the "storehouse." 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

In the Old Testament, tithing was a way for the Israelites to support their priestly tribe, the Levites, who did no work outside of sacred duties. The word "tithe" appears in the entire Old Testament only 27 times, mostly in passing. There are only five places where it is discussed in any detail, and they are conflicting. In some cases tithing happened yearly (see Deut. 14:22), but elsewhere it was commanded every third year (see Deut. 26:12, 14:28 and Amos 4:4). The Levites themselves gave a "tithe of tithes" to the high priest Aaron (Numbers 18). But tithing was not just for supporting the ministry; you could use tithes as general charity to help "the stranger, the fatherless, and the widow" (Deut. 26:12). The tithe was 10% of everything you earned or produced, including grain, fruit, and meat (presented as a "burnt offering"). You could borrow against your tithe, for a 20 percent fee (Lev. 27:30-34). You could sell your tithes for cash and indulge yourself, as long as you didn't forget the Levites (Deut. 14:26-27). I was surprised to learn that tithes were meant to be consumed mainly by the tither! (It made sense to dispose of meat quickly in that part of the world.) The only restrictions were that tithes be eaten in certain holy places, that the blood be avoided, and that some remain for the Levites (Deut. 12:6-19, 14:22-28). 

Bethiepoo --- 19 years ago -

We also donate to kids at LakeWood for their mission trips.. ;) God has already blessed me.. ;) 

MissT --- 19 years ago -

yes, but that seems to be the only real basis...even that is thin. When God seems to really care about an issue, it is backed up several times and it is not a gray area... Leviticus 27:30 'Thus all the tithe of the land, of the seed of the land or of the fruit of the tree, is the LORD'S; it is holy to the LORD. 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

Tithe=10 Malichi 3:8 There are several references in the Old Testament. Some people do not believe it is required anymore because it is Old Testament. Look up Tithe in the back of your Bible and it will give you the scriptures. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

Beyond Mt. Sinai, the tithe is seldom mentioned in the Old Testament, surfacing only during the reforms of Hezekiah (2 Chr 31:5), Nehemiah (Neh 10:38), and Malachi (Mat 3:8-12). In those times the tithe was either being abused or ignored altogether 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

Matt 23:23 - "Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You give a tenth of your spices--mint, dill and cummin. But you have neglected the more important matters of the law--justice, mercy and faithfulness. You should have practiced the latter, without neglecting the former. In the above scripture Jesus is upset with the pharasees...if they were so religous with their tithe, then they should also be with their mercy and compassion 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

10% belongs to God. Is that too much to ask for all that He gives us. It does not belong to anyone else. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

1 Cor 16:2 - On the first day of every week, each one of you should set aside a sum of money in keeping with his income, saving it up, so that when I come no collections will have to be made. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

10% belongs to God. Is that too much to ask for all that He gives us. It does not belong to anyone else. The Gospel is obscured when preachers, by way of a gross misinterpretation of God's call to faith in Malachi 3, entice people into greater giving by appealing to their fleshly, selfish desires: "If only you would give more money to church, you would have unparalleled business success and two new cars in your garage." Such talk turns Gospel giving into a business deal - "If you do this, God will do that" - and striking a deal with God is totally contrary to the Gospel. Even worse, business-deal language smacks of manipulation, the thought that God can be manipulated into doing this or that through one's own activity. This kind of divine manipulation characterized all the pagan Canaanite religions that surrounded the nation of Israel. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

10% belongs to God. Is that too much to ask for all that He gives us. It does not belong to anyone else. No, and again there may not be a real answer. I am a church going Christian, I tithe, read, and pray...I feel led to give. Just because I have doubts and questions does not make me ungreatful for what God has done. But, everytime I have asked finance people in my church they have not given a direct answer other than Malachi 3. They all get offended then talk about a heart issue...but is it? 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

No deals with God, but the tithe is 10% 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

No deals with God, but the tithe is 10% you just proved my point... 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

and your point was? 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

If you feel that the money is not being used well at the church you go to and that they are not being good stewards of Gods money then you need to find a church that makes you feel excited to give and wistful that you could not give more. There should be great joy attached to your giving. I think that may be what it boils down to. Our current church use to be into outside ministries and it seems like over the past year or so they have slowly backed out of it...then it makes me wonder what I am tithing for - especially when I see each month how much our small church spends. SO, with this being said - we haven't been tithing the %10, but giving more to ministries that are helping the poor and other ministries. We are currently looking for a new church, but that doesn't erase my questions or doubts. I KNOW that it means I still need to press forward and keep what faith I have...baby steps. My question was not to offend or raise doubt in others (I thought about the latter as I was just wiping down my table), but was wondering if there was really a clear cut answer. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

and your point was? That people seem to get offended when they can't back something up. You may not have, but you were short - I of course may have misunderstood - it won't be the first time or the last I am sure. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

Here is another question for you. What about the Christians who do not belong to a formal church. Are they not tithing by giving to local charities? 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

I wish Christians could be more honest with each other when dealing with doubts and questions...even Billy Grahm lived with doubts and questions. It is faith that keeps us in the race, not our actions, doubts or other concerns that pop up. Certain topics I guess are just taboo with Christians... 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

Here is another question for you. What about the Christians who do not belong to a formal church. Are they not tithing by giving to local charities? I personally think they are... That is another thing that comes up with my questions - am I still not giving %10 or more by blessing other ministries or needs. 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

I was short because it is very simple to me..........tithe is 10% and it goes to the church. It is backed up with scripture. Steve said it very well. If you give to charities or the person down the street that needs shoes, that is not a tithe. I agree with Steve, if you have doubts about your own church and don't feel that they are good stewards of the funds they are given, then start looking for a new one. I am definitely not offended, just a firm believer in tithing to the church. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

Steve said it very well. If you give to charities or the person down the street that needs shoes, that is not a tithe. I agree with Steve, if you have doubts about your own church and don't feel that they are good stewards of the funds they are given, then start looking for a new one. again, we are in the process of looking for a new church. you can read my prior thread. Glad I didn't offend you. The organization of church is relativly new in the history time table...so, i disagree that giving to your church and other Christian based organizations is against scripture in reguards to the tithe issue. Especially if we are seperating out at least %10 of our paychecks to make sure we are giving it back to God. 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

We agree to disagree on that issue. We also contribute to KSBJ and to a building fund, and basically to anyone that needs it, BUT for us, that is after the 10% to the church. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

We agree to disagree on that issue. We also contribute to KSBJ and to a building fund, and basically to anyone that needs it, BUT for us, that is after the 10% to the church. That is probably the most honest answer I have ever recieved - honestly. When I have asked questions about money issues, they bring out a few scriptures, well, I know them as well. I know that what I am going through is a heart issue, but so does God, and I believe that HE will pull me through. I HATE looking for new churches, but feel that we just can't stay where we are at and go forward with God, or atleast become the Christians that we want to become. You answered with "BUT, for us..." which believe it or not is refreshing. My husband and I are praying through this though. Maybe God is putting other ministries in our hearts to keep us tithing atleast the %10 until we find a new church - who knows. =) 

55andunder --- 19 years ago -

Luke 6:38 - give, and it shall be given unto you; good measure, pressed down, shaken together, running over, shall men give unto your bosom. For with what measure ye mete it shall be measured to you again. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

As long as you don't lie about it like ananias........ ;o) My husband and I were just discussing that last night - what power the apostles had!! See, ananias wasn't struck down because he didn't give, he was struck down because of the lie and heart issue behind the lie. 

Cindi --- 19 years ago -

I know that God says when you tithe you will be blessed in return. I have a friend whose husband is out of work. She is working and not really making any money. She is very firm in titheing. Actually she pays her tithes before she pays everything else. and believe it or not everything always fall into place for them. I have actually said to her "I don't know how ya'll are making it" Some weeks she brings in $250-$350.00. She says God always takes care of them. She told me one day they were literally broke and when she went to the mailbox to get her mail there was a plain envelope with $200.00 in it. She said that even though it was probably someone from church she know that is a blessing from God. 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

Actually she pays her tithes before she pays everything else. and believe it or not everything always fall into place for them. We have been there...and we still tithed. Again, it's not that I don't believe in tithing, I just have questions. My husband made about $900.00 working FULL TIME, went to school full time, and God blessed us with every need we had. We did not tithe off school loans just the actual money we earned. Just because someone has questions doesn't mean they disapprove of it or has not been blessed by it. 

Mary C --- 19 years ago -

Just because someone has questions doesn't mean they disapprove of it or has not been blessed by it. Questions allow us to hear different points of view. Some we may agree with and some we disagree with. We all have to remain teachable. 

blessed --- 19 years ago -

When my husband first started his own business, we had to really learn what faith meant. The first month he made only $500 and our rent alone was $590 and I had no job. W/out telling the whole testimony, we realized that we had to give everything we had to God. He was the supplier of our needs and only He could provide. To this day, we have looked at the $ that my hubby makes as GODS money. It's not ours. We tithe our 10% unless we feel led to add more. However, we pray over that tithe and the money left over allowing God to lead us on what we should do with that $. We support missionaries, friends in need, and so on because God has led us to. We view our money as His and He can do whatever HE wants with it. It gave us such a freedom to allow God to provide ALL things for our family. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

I loved that Blessed! Great way to put it. My question was based on what I have read on here. There are some good Christian people, they hang out with good people. They just do not go to any certain church. But they do give and help out those in need. So when they give to those in need are they still not tithing? 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Tithing was a command given to the nation of Israel by God through the Mosaic law in the Old Covenant. Jesus fulfilled the Mosaic law and instituted the law of Christ with a New Covenant of grace. Therefore, Christians are not under ANY commandment or requirement to tithe. Nowhere does the New Testament command tithing as a regulation for the Church - the body of Christ. Neither Jesus nor his disciples taught the necessity of tithing. To demand a tenth from believers would be disobedience to the principles of giving by grace given to us by God in 2 Corinthians Chapters 8 and 9, and 1 Corinthians 16:2. An emphasis on tithing can lead to a sense of compulsion (giving as a duty) and even complacency (I have already met my quota) and become a limitation to greater giving. The NT teaches in 1 Corinthians 16:1-3 and 2 Corinthians Chapters 8 and 9, that a Christian's giving should be regular, cheerful and generous as an expression of love, in proportion to income. For the Christian, giving is a matter of individual conscience, a voluntary decision before God, and is subject to the inward prompting of the Holy Spirit, and not to be controlled by the external commands of others. "But this I say, He which soweth sparingly shall reap also sparingly; and he which soweth bountifully shall reap also bountifully. Every man according as he purposeth in his heart, so let him give; not grudgingly, or of necessity: for God loveth a cheerful giver. And God is able to make all grace abound toward you; that ye, always having all sufficiency in all things, may abound to every good work: As it is written, He hath dispersed abroad; he hath given to the poor: his righteousness remaineth for ever." (2 Corinthians 9:6-9) A Christian should not ask, "What am I required to give?" but should ask "How much can I give?" It would be surprising if grace did not encourage a larger proportion of one's wealth than what the Mosaic Law demanded. Compulsory tithing makes law keeping a means of earning God's approval. Legalism enters the Christian life when obedience to God is not based on faith, grace and love. Legalism is defined as a doctrine of salvation by conformity to law, as contrasted by the New Covenant teachings of salvation by grace. To insist on tithing in the age of grace is to mix law and grace and encourage trust in human works. Christians are subject to the law of Christ: "To them that are without law, as without law, (being not without law to God, but under the law to Christ,) that I might gain them that are without law." (1 Corinthians 9:21 "Bear ye one another's burdens, and so fulfil the law of Christ." (Galatians 6:2) The standard for how much we Christians give is not an amount set by some external law. If a set amount is laid down for believers to give, it becomes a legal and external matter, rather than a matter of the individual's conscience and the leading of the Holy Spirit: "Stand fast therefore in the liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free, and be not entangled again with the yoke of bondage...But if ye be led of the Spirit, ye are not under the law...If we live in the Spirit, let us also walk in the Spirit." (Galatians 5:1,18,25). A Christian should give a proportion based on what one has, one's own needs, and on the needs of others, including the ministry of the body of Christ. In other words, giving is not tied to the support of a brick and mortar building. 

biker-mom --- 19 years ago -

If we get our finances under His order of discipline then he will bless the 90% we have left and it will go farther and do more than the 100% would if we had kept it. I have to agree... when we began tithing we should have had LESS money to work with...but somehow it has gone futher and we are not only caught up on our bills..we are (for the 1st time) actually ahead. It took me along time to GET it. For me it is about faith. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

A Christian should give a proportion based on what one has, one's own needs, and on the needs of others. In other words, giving is not tied to the support of a brick and mortar building.  Thanks bb. I do know there are some people who really are good Christians. But they do not belong to any one church. I've known them for years. They do not associate with a bad crowd, they just do not beleive in organized religion. Yet they are the first one to help someone in need. I do go to church and I love the feeling of being in church and hearing so many Christians lifining thier voices up to God. I need this and look forward to it. Some do not. But they are not any less of a Christian because of it. 

Fallon --- 19 years ago -

And totally off the subject, this is the first time I've ever used the quote feature, and I am so proud of myself! :) 

2coolboyz --- 19 years ago -

I agree BB... That has been the issue with other Christians when we ask...the only answer we ever get is "it's in Malachi", or we are commanded too. Thank you for not commanding me to tithe out of duty. I still think that if I only tithe %5 with a cheerful heart that it would be better than tithing %10, %15 or more out of duty. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground