Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Parent wants classic novel out of school

who's talking here?

mugglemom 1
4x4mom 1
freshhell 1
Unichic 3
GCan 14
lindagail 3
Scottie's Hottie 1
Fallon 7
eterry2 1
planemom 1
Danabug(BCM) 2
Karen #'s 2
April 1
Sandyr9111 1
likeke27 5
girlsRus 1
lilmommy 1
keh 4
jemezchick 5
AuthorMan 2
myself 3
lonesophist 12
TXamanda 8
*emily 9
Mabbers 3
Cicero 1
Setta-Don-Naw 9
Rachel 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

TXamanda --- 19 years ago -

i saw this on channel 11 website and maybe that is why the news vans were at Atascocita High last night. this book is a classic, but i have to say i ahve never read it. 

TXamanda --- 19 years ago -

also how do i post the story, is it legal to copy paste it on here?:o) 

Karen #'s --- 19 years ago -

What is the title of the book? 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

Copy the link that the story is on and post the link. 

TXamanda --- 19 years ago -

of mice and men 

TXamanda --- 19 years ago -

http://www.khou.com/topstories/stories/khou070501_tj_miceandmen.2a01c156.html 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

The book says the N word a lot and a LOT of people find it offensive for very good reason. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 19 years ago -

Mice and Men 

TXamanda --- 19 years ago -

i know the word is offensive, but to ban a classic book like that. there has to be better way. well if they ban it, maybe they can read it in college then:) 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

In my opinion it can be suggested reading or provided in the library. But such offensive language shouldn't be forced on people who cringe everytime they read or hear it. 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

:) 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

I disagree with any book banning (big surprise, I know). I also think that literature taught in the schools can actually encourage tolerance, versus hiding everything away through censorship and leaving children to never have serious discussions about language and its progression throughout history. In life, it's not the words that are offensive, it's the way they're used. We cannot rewrite history and change the way people spoke during certain time periods just to be PC. 

girlsRus --- 19 years ago -

Both of my older girls had to read this in their AP classes, never heard of any problems from it 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

That is all true Lone. I myself try not to use certain language so I try not to expose myself to it as well. Same as swear words. If a book said the F word every few paragraphs I wouldn't continue to read it. 

TXamanda --- 19 years ago -

In my opinion it can be suggested reading or provided in the library. But such offensive language shouldn't be forced on people who cringe everytime they read or hear it. it must be pretty bad, there are so many books to choose from. I just remember "to kill a mocking bird" had some in it too and i would hate to see it banned. like i said there has to be an alternative to a complete ban on books with the "N" word. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

Why are the students reading it? to analize and discuss the book? They are learning from it, the rights and the WRONGS. I say leave it. 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

I read that book in school and I honestly do not remember that word being in there. I was surprised when I saw the news story about that book in particular. I would have thought it would have been something else. 

4x4mom --- 19 years ago -

oh great....another...soap box to get QuanellX in tv..... 

keh --- 19 years ago -

I had to read that book in middle school and I don't remember it being offensive. The N word is, but I don't think it made me think differently about other races. 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

I didn't say I wanted it banned. But when I was in high school, if the material was questionable, or offensive to a student, they were given an alternative book. It was their choice and less than a handful would actually do it. But I thought that was what was fair for them. :) 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

I love that book! What a crock. If you start banning that book, then you'll have to ban Huck Finn, Tom Sawyer and a bunch of other classic books that whether you like it or not, express a point of view or sentiment from a particular time and place in our history. Because you remove this book doesn't mean you're going to erase the fact that people used a particular word back then and that it's still used today. To focus on this one thing in the book, is just ridiculous. 

mugglemom --- 19 years ago -

I read that book in school and I honestly do not remember that word being in there. me too! 

myself --- 19 years ago -

i don't think anything should be "banned" but i do think that when there is an assignment, there should be a list of books to choose from...not just one assigned 

myself --- 19 years ago -

that would satisfy everyone 

Sandyr9111 --- 19 years ago -

Because you remove this book doesn't mean you're going to erase the fact that people used a particular word back then and that it's still used today. To focus on this one thing in the book, is just ridiculous. I agree. Alot of the older books use that word. It was VERY common many years ago. What I dont get is it is ok for them to call themselves that "N" word but they dont want to read it in a book? 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

but i do think that when there is an assignment, there should be a list of books to choose from...not just one assigned That's difficult, though, when there is going to be class discussion on a particular book. 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

How do these book banning parents expect their children to excel at the college level when they won't be fully prepared literary wise if they do not study these classics? 

Karen #'s --- 19 years ago -

I read this book in high school, I was not scared for life. There was a discussion prior to reading the book stating that the book is controvercial to some. They also discussed that during that time, this was the way people spoke and that society has evolved since, then compared the two generations. If there is a discussion where the children can compare the generations to see the progression of our society then I think the use of this book is ok. If the teacher is just going to tell them to read it and write a report and nothing is learned, then the book was used incorrectly. 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

My children are bi-racial and to read a book with the "N" word in there over and over again would be disheartening to them. They are not so sheltered that they have never heard the word, my son has been called one by classmates on occasion. I would rather they be given an alternative book to read and report on. 

jemezchick --- 19 years ago -

How do these book banning parents expect their children to excel at the college level when they won't be fully prepared literary wise if they do not study these classics? Perhaps the parents do not have a higher education to understand this, just a thought. 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

I don't think anyone is getting what I am saying... I am white and there isn't really a word that I can think of that encompasses all that the N word means to some black people. Yes it is a part of all of our pasts and present, it is still used today, but seriously, for a black student going to school being forced to read it... That would just suck for them. If it doesn't and they can get past the language and enjoy the story that is great. It is a good story. But it should be a CHOICE. Forcing it is just as bad as censoring it in my humble opinion. 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

What I dont get is it is ok for them to call themselves that "N" word but they dont want to read it in a book? That is stereotyping. Not all of "them" say it... 

Unichic --- 19 years ago -

hiding everything away through censorship and leaving children to never have serious discussions about language and its progression throughout history. In life, it's not the words that are offensive, it's the way they're used. We cannot rewrite history and change the way people spoke during certain time periods just to be PC. I agree, and also, one day hopefully in my lifetime, the N word will no longer be in our vocabulary, so the verbiage in this book will truly be historic. We only cringe because people are still walking around using the "N" word like they were saying "foot"...... WHat am I thinking? With some of the mentalities on this site alone, we will NEVER get to a place where tolerance, instead of racism exists. 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

There are a lot worse things that are on television, cable, video games, the news that I would be more concerned about. Why not protest all that garbage as well? (rhetorical question I guess). 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I went to a predominantly white school growing up. We never had a student of another race until my second year of high school. We read many books that others may have found offensive. I never thought anything of it at the time. Seeing those words in books just reinforced that we had come a long way in society. 

myself --- 19 years ago -

How do these book banning parents expect their children to excel at the college level when they won't be fully prepared literary wise if they do not study these classics? have to say..being "literary wise" did nothing for me in my adult life!!!! 

Unichic --- 19 years ago -

It was VERY common many years ago I still hear the word used. 

TXamanda --- 19 years ago -

Emily, i get what your saying!!:) and what i can tell is there is a choice, right now for the students. but what this parent wants, from my understanding, is for it to be remove dand no student should read it. And my children are young now and i too am white, wheni cross that brige in many years i may not want my children to read those books, but i to would like to have the choice.JMHO 

*emily --- 19 years ago -

Thats what I am saying Amanda. Choice. I said I didn't think it should be banned. But for those who find it offensive, they should be given another book like some were in our high school. (we went to the same place.) :) 

Rachel --- 19 years ago -

What I dont get is it is ok for them to call themselves that "N" word but they dont want to read it in a book? This is a word that we do not use in our home...period. We are careful as to what we allow our children to watch on TV as well. Most of my kids friends parents do the same (black and white). I just saw an update on the news and it says that Humble ISD is allowing the kids who object to the book to choose an alternative. I think that is great! 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

parenting


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground